Freudians at War: “On the surface, this is a parochial argument about labels and credentials, a tempest in a Viennese teacup — or at most, a professional turf war. But you don’t have to probe the protagonists too deeply to discover that this is also a battle over the nature of therapy itself — what it is, what it does, how it works. And it quickly becomes apparent that alongside the intellectual controversy is a bare knuckles fight over money, power and prestige. These people, after all, are professionals of the ego.” (New York Times)
Author Archives: FmH
The Fate of the Soul
“Centuries of “experimental philosophy” and cognitive neuroscience have led to a revolutionary understanding of how the brain makes the mind.” Neuroscientist and psychiatrist William Calvin reviews Soul Made Flesh: The Discovery of the Brain—and How It Changed the World by Carl Zimmer and The Birth of the Mind:
How a Tiny Number of Genes Creates
the Complexities of Human Thought
by Gary Marcus. (Natural History Magazine)
US demands war crimes immunity
“But human rights campaigners said the Iraq prison abuse scandal proves that the US needs to be held to account.
‘Given the recent revelations… the US has picked one hell of a moment to ask for special treatment,’ said Richard Dicker of Human Rights Watch.” (BBC via the null device)
The Ladies Love Us (not)
“I’m a bit surprised that there hasn’t been more discussion of the overwhelmingly male (on the order of 80%) cast of political blog readership. At first glance, one might think of this as an internet issue, related to hardy perennials regarding women and technology in general, but I think it’s a manifestation of the broader fact that women don’t seem very interested in politics. All the political magazines have overwhelmingly male readerships, and surveys consistently show that women are less informed about politics than men, even when you do controls for income and educational attainment. I saw one book which alleged that women are even less likely than men to be able to correctly identify a candidate’s position on abortion, despite the CW that women care about this more than men. Indeed, the research even showed that women do care about this more than men, in that among those who knew where the candidates stood, it was more likely to be a factor in women’s voting decisions.
So I have no idea why that is, and it probably has some deep and mysterious roots out there somewhere. On the other hand, one thing I’ve long thought is that following politics is less the manifestation of high-minded concern for public affairs that we junkies would like to think of it as, and more like sports fandom — a semi-arbitrary decision to follow something and develop an emotional attachment to a team just because it’s fun. Certainly women don’t watch as much sports as men, even though there’s been tremendous growth in women’s participation (which has a pretty different appeal — I wouldn’t care to play tackle football, but it’s fun to watch) in athletics over the past several decades.”
Looking at the comments to Yglesias’ challenge, I think the difference is real and facetious attempts to put it down to a difference in online polltaking miss the boat. In so doing they prevent us from acknowledging the meaningfulness of the observation.
Both the comment about politics being like sport and the comment about the different modes of discourse men and women use are part of the answer (not that there is one answer that explains it all). Psychologically, Carol Gilligan explained several decades ago the developmental roots of fundamental psychological differences between males and females. Although I am being reductionistic, women are embedded in relationship and maintain interpersonal liaison, while men are confrontive and competitive and their relationships more often disjunctive.
The modern political process in the US is relentlessly mean-spirited, amplifying of distinctions between oneself and one’s opponent, and conciliation and concession are seen as weakness. Statistically, this would be abhorrent to more women than men, although the male “sissies” on the Left who are better able to embrace the feminine in themselves share their female compatriots’ disdain more often for the little men (usually white) playing with their toys in Washington with a deluded sense of their own importance. (Months ago, I published a link in my weblog to a piece of software that claimed, by analyzing a prose sample, to tell if the writer was male or female. A large element of what it looked for was the syntax of disjunction vs. the syntax of connectedness. By the way, I was complimented by its opinion that my writing was feminine…)
I suspect that in more mature democracies than that of the US, the disparity between men’s and women’s participation would be lessened, especially in those where (a) political discourse remains civil, and (b) coalition is necessary to govern.
What do you expect from someone who idolized Strom Thurmond and was stupid enough to advertise the fact? (The Washington Monthly)
Gore’s MoveOn Remarks
I read Gore’s speech and thought of the Presidents who become elder statesmen after they leave office, unencumbered by the need to build a national constituency and able to speak from truth instead of power. Gore seems to have bypassed the President phase and gone right to the statesman-like. He eloquently encapsulates the extent of Bush’s betrayal of American ideals with a quiet but sustained outrage and concludes with some between-the-lines regret that he acquiesced to the theft of the Presidency from him by the Supreme Court in order to “do what I could to prevent efforts to delegitimize George Bush as he took the oath of office.” Has there been any talk of what role he might have within, or as an advisor to, a Kerry administration?
"…Iranians had us for breakfast, lunch and dinner…"
US intelligence fears Iran duped hawks into Iraq war:
Some intelligence officials now believe that Iran used the hawks in the Pentagon and the White House to get rid of a hostile neighbour, and pave the way for a Shia-ruled Iraq.” (Guardian.UK)
"Yet another nostalgic old codger complaining about the state of contemporary music…"
Rock of Ages: “”Youth is a quality not unlike health: it’s found in greater abundance among the young, but we all need access to it. (And not all young people are lucky enough to be young. Think of those people at your college who wanted to be politicians or corporate lawyers, for example.) I’m not talking about the accouterments of youth: the unlined faces, the washboard stomachs, the hair. The young are welcome to all that — what would we do with it anyway? I’m talking about the energy, the wistful yearning, the inexplicable exhilaration, the sporadic sense of invincibility, the hope that stings like chlorine. When I was younger, rock music articulated these feelings, and now that I’m older it stimulates them, but either way, rock ‘n’ roll was and remains necessary because: who doesn’t need exhilaration and a sense of invincibility, even if it’s only now and again?
When I say that I have found these feelings harder and harder to detect these last few years, I understand that I run the risk of being seen as yet another nostalgic old codger complaining about the state of contemporary music. And though it’s true that I’m an old codger, and that I’m complaining about the state of contemporary music, I hope that I can wriggle out of the hole I’m digging for myself by moaning that, to me, contemporary rock music no longer sounds young — or at least, not young in that kind of joyous, uninhibited way. In some ways, it became way too grown-up and full of itself. You can find plenty that’s angry, or weird, or perverse, or melancholy and world-weary; but that loud, sometimes dumb celebration of being alive has got lost somewhere along the way. Of course we want to hear songs about Iraq, and child prostitution, and heroin addiction. And if bands see the need to use electric drills instead of guitars in order to give vent to their rage, well, bring it on. But is there any chance we could have the Righteous Brothers’ “Little Latin Lupe Lu” — or, better still, a modern-day equivalent — for an encore?” — Nick Hornby, (The New York Times Op-Ed)
I don’t know about Hornby, but as an over-50 listener to rock-and-roll I am still finding alot in my listening, new and old, that inspires exuberance and a singing-out-loud (but when I am alone in the car with the windows up) type of joy… Having an iPod and finding alot of new music through the mp3-blogs has put me onto alot of indie rock that amazes me, and I have yet to hear anything about Iraq or child prostitution.
Oh, and, while we’re at it, if us old codgers are able never to outgrow our rocking, why can’t some of you young upstarts get into classical music? (Boston Globe op-ed)
Go to the Movies to Stop Global Warming
The Day Before Tomorrow at Your Local Movie Theater: MoveOn is organizing a drive to leaflet viewers exiting movie theaters from tomorrow’s opening day showings of The Day After, the Hollywood disaster blockbuster about global warming. It is a rare opportunity to engage voters at a time they may be most concerned about environmental catastrophe and impress them with the disastrous course we have been led down under the Bush regime. You can download this .pdf and print out flyers to distribute. Friday afternoon showings are important because the chances of press coverage are greatest on opening day. Sign up.
The body of the future:
High-tech homo sapiens: “Currently, having a 200-year lifespan or an intelligence quotient double that of Marilyn Vos Savant might seem pretty far out. But some enhancement advocates are even more creative. Right now, over at a website associated with the World Transhumanist Association, a community of people is eager to get bioengineered bodies as soon as possible. Here’s the running list—half tongue-in-cheek—of some of the possible body modifications.” —James Pethokoukis, US News
Study: DVRs ‘Recapture’ 96% Of TV Ad Zapping
In other words, TiVo viewers watch more commercials:
“Digital video recorders (DVR) typically are seen as the ultimate threat to TV advertising, giving consumers unsurpassed control over what they choose to watch or not watch on their TV sets, including TV commercials. And while it is true that most DVR subscribers do fast-forward through TV commercials when watching programming in replay mode, new research indicates that the net effect of DVRs actually increases the likelihood that viewers will see a TV commercial not decrease it.” (Media Daily News)
The main reason for this is that, with overall higher TV viewing satisfaction, TiVo viewers watch more TV overall. Even though they zap through a number of commercials, on net it appears they watch more than non-TiVo viewers. I know this is not true for me; I skip virtually 100% of TV advertising, especially since I enabled the 30-second skip hack, making skipping an ad dead simple. If studies such as this reassure the powers that be that they do not have to fight a pitched battle against the DVRs, I am all for it.
Annals of Depravity (cont’d.):
UN troops buy sex from teenage refugees in Congo camp:
“Teenage rape victims fleeing war in the Democratic Republic of Congo are being sexually exploited by the United Nations peace-keeping troops sent to the stop their suffering.
The Independent has found that mothers as young as 13 – the victims of multiple rape by militiamen – can only secure enough food to survive in the sprawling refugee camp by routinely sleeping with UN peace-keepers.” (Independent.UK)
I don’t suppose anyone ought to be surprised to find that the US has no monopoly on this kind of barbarity. It gives you pause about the UN peacekeepers being the kneejerk choice to supplant the American Huns in the Iraqi occupation, though…
‘New Developments in Political Protest’ Dept:
A group of feisty rabble-rousing women has found “this way of just mobilizing, energizing, inspiring”. Could the Axis of Eve become George W. Bush’s worst nightmare? SF Chronicle
‘Artists will see their music help some of the poorest people in the world’
The charity will offer 300,000 songs to download through its Big Noise Music website, which launches on Wednesday.
Tracks will cost between 75p and 99p, with 10p going to Oxfam.” (BBC)
Lost Boy: In Search of Nick Drake
![Bryter Later [Image 'bryterlayter99.jpg' cannot be displayed]](https://i0.wp.com/www.bbc.co.uk/radio2/images/documentaries/nickdrake/bryterlayter99.jpg)
A BBC Radio 2 documentary narrated by Brad Pitt, who was approached once producers found out he is a huge fan. As someone who was listening to Drake before his 1974 death, I have to look askance at those who, like Pitt, found him in the last five years, since his recurrent popularity was propelled by — what was it? — a VW commercial? Still, you could do far worse…
A Book in You
The Talk of the Town? Further evidence of the continued crossover of weblogging into the mainstream, as if we needed it.
Although my wife keeps pushing me to write “something useful” instead of this weblog, I am not sure there is a book in me… or that anyone would ask.
‘Rumsfeld Prohibits Cell Phone Cameras’ a fake?
AFP may have picked up a three-week old satirical piece from The Daily Farce as if it were news. When I read it, I was curious that this was not being reported more broadly. Does life imitate art or is truth far stranger than fiction could ever be these days? There has been an accumulating series of stories in which satirical stories, usually from The Onion, are picked up by the news media and reported as true, but those have usually been in the non-Western press which perhaps can be excused for not grasping the subtleties of skillful Western tongue-in-cheek. If this story was an invention, one is prompted to wonder what has become of the Sydney Morning Herald‘s fact checkers? and of their sense of humor?
Gen. Zinni: ‘They’ve Screwed Up’
If you missed it, here is a transcript of Gen. Anthony Zinni’s remarks on 60 Minutes. (CBS News)
Annals of the Invasion of Privacy (cont’d.):
Although officials would release few details about the initiative, the identity checks will mark the first time local rail and subway passengers will be asked to produce identification and be questioned about their activities.” (Boston Globe)
Rumsfeld bans camera phones in Iraq
Quoting a Pentagon source, the paper said the US Defence Department believes that some of the damning photos of US soldiers abusing Iraqis at Abu Ghraib prison near Baghdad were taken with camera phones.
‘Digital cameras, camcorders and cellphones with cameras have been prohibited in military compounds in Iraq,’ it said, adding that a ‘total ban throughout the US military’ is in the works.” (Sydney Morning Herald)
Ethnologue
This is essentially a catalogue/encyclopedia of all the extant languages of the world. It is the labor of the Summer Institute on Linguistics, which takes the business of learning and teaching indigenous languages seriously since it exists to train missionaries to speak the languages of the heathens they go to live among for the purpose, among others, of producing a translation of the Bible into the local tongue (and, where the local speakers have no writing system, throwing one in as part of the bargain). The Summer Institute has a complicated relationship with those doing ethnographic research and indigenous rights advocacy, who generally stand against the cultural imperialism of conversion work but unabashedly reap the benefits of its linguistic trailblazing in many regions such as Central America, where I worked as an undergraduate doing ethnographic research. Here’s the entry for the indigenous language I used to speak, for example.
The Ethnologue also exists in book and CD form, since there are probably still places the SIL goes where there are no broadband connections. [via Kevin Kelly’s Cool Tools]
The SIL also offers a suite of computerized tools for linguistic field work, which sound very powerful. Perusing this stuff makes me wistful for my fieldwork days (which was before even the days of the laptop; I wonder, by the by, if there have been any anthropological monographs on the impact of the advent of computers and computerized research techniques on the indigenous people anthropologists go to study). I used to say that there had been a natural transition between being an anthropologist and becoming a psychiatrist; that clinical psychiatry is an exploration of the cross-cultural differences between oneself and the neighbors in one’s own culture [and sometimes the ethnopharmacology as well], but it is just not the same. Perhaps I ought to make housecalls, since I loved the fieldwork experience so well.
In any case, here’s SIL’s fascinating-sounding suite of linguistic software tools:
- LinguaLinks Library 5.0:
Provides information, instructions, training, and advice in a ‘show-and-tell’ mode designed to support fieldwork. Contains the entire contents of 223 journal issues, 149 online books, glossaries, bibliographies, and other reference resources. Includes useful computer applications for language learning and literacy.
- The Linguist’s Shoebox 5.0:
SIL’s classic language data manager, now with additional features and improved ease-of-use.
- SIL FieldWorks 1.4:
A suite of software tools to help language teams manage cultural data, with support for complex scripts.
- Speech Tools 2.0:
A suite of software that enables you to record, store, and analyze language sounds and music, as well as to help you in language learning.
- LinguaLinks Workshops 5.0:
A world-class tool for managing lexical semantic and text data.
- Language data management and analysis software:
SIL Language Software 1.0 and the individual subsets include several stand-alone programs. Some are to carry out auxiliary functions. Others are included as supplemental resources for language workers.
- Character sets and fonts:
Provides generic character sets, language definitions, and keyboard files as well as methods to create encodings for your language definition from one or more existing character sets.
- WordSurv 4.0 for Windows:
Tool for comparative analysis of word lists to help determine linguistic relationships.
Judge appoints attorney for dog
“Lake Circuit Judge Lorenzo Arredondo appointed an attorney Thursday to represent Cabic at a hearing to determine whether he is a wolf-dog hybrid.
For Cabic, the outcome is a matter of life and death.”
Yeah, but what lurks in the chest hairs poking out through the open collar??
Nearly half the neckties worn by 42 doctors at the New York Hospital Medical Center of Queen’s (NYHMCQ) contained bacteria which can cause dangerous conditions like pneumonia and blood infections, the researchers found.
‘This study brings into question whether wearing a necktie is in the best interest of our patients,’ says NYHMCQ’s Steven Nurkin, who led the team.” (New Scientist)
Where to Get a Good Idea:
Most likely, says Ronald S. Burt, a sociologist at the University of Chicago, it came from someone else who hadn’t realized how to use it.
‘The usual image of creativity is that it’s some sort of genetic gift, some heroic act,’ Mr. Burt said. ‘But creativity is an import-export game. It’s not a creation game.'” (New York Times)
Also: Thumbing His Nose at Academe, a Scholar Tries to Auction His Services:
What ever happened to the amber room?
The Big Lie
…A fanciful explanation for the two realities is that the United States is the continent-wide set for a large scale re-enactment of the movie The Truman Show. The plot of that movie has the well-intentioned but naive hero go about his daily life without any suspicion that he is, in fact, in a gigantic soap opera. His hometown is actually the set for the TV show and from earliest childhood he has been manipulated and controlled by the producer and the director. The enthusiastic acceptance by the American multitudes of the Iraqi stuff-and-nonsense coming out of the White House would be understandable if we were all living on a stage set in a village called Freedom Island threatened by a town called Evil Axis.
Americans believed, as they usually do when their government and their television tell them something, but the rest of the world laughed every time George Bush or Colin Powell or Dick Cheney or Donald Rumsfeld thought up yet one more scary reason to invade Iraq. The ill-constructed, clumsy untruths were surprisingly crude for people who have had years to practice the craft of mass deception, and they had only to speak their latest falsehood to be cheered by their countrymen and disbelieved by non-Americans everywhere.
It’s not easy to pull off the Big Lie and George Bush failed; though, in mitigation, pulling off a bait-and-switch war demands skillful finagling and this one was complicated. There was the bait (terrorism), then the switch (weapons of mass destruction), then a switch again (kill the dictator), and yet again (regime change). A politician has to be an accomplished teller of tall tales and absurd fabrications to bring off such a demarché. Even the masters of mass prevarication occasionally fail. ” — excerpted from Hoax: Why Americans Are Suckered by White House Lies by Nicholas von Hoffman, a columnist for the New York Observer. (AlterNet)
Ex-U.S. Marine: I Killed Civilians in Iraq
Now another US soldier who participated in the Iraq invasion and occupation has begun speaking out. Twelve year Marine veteran Jimmy Massey…talks about his time in Iraq where he admitted the U.S. treatment of Iraqi civilians is fueling the Iraqi resistance. In a recent interview he said “I felt like we were committing genocide in Iraq.” ‘ (Democracy Now!)
Why America’s top liberal lawyer wants to legalise torture
And would you legalise this, Mr. Dershowitz?? Pentagon admits to 37 prisoner deaths:
Eight of the deaths are classified as murder involving suspected assaults on detainees before or during interrogation sessions.
The deaths are from 33 incidents – eight more cases than the Pentagon publicly reported two weeks ago.
Meanwhile, a British soldier is facing criminal charges following the alleged killing of an Iraqi civilian.” (The Scotsman)
‘…a gateway to the magnificence of the actual…’
![Allen Ginsberg [Image 'ginsberg.jpg' cannot be displayed]](ginsberg.jpg)
Ginsberg’s Celestial Homework: A “specialized Reading List for ‘Literary History of the Beat Generation,’ a course taught by Allen Ginsberg at Naropa Institute during the summer of 1977.” The original reading list (page 1, page 2, and page 3) has been reverently turned into a web page — into which I could submerge myself for a long time — by journalist-psychonaut Steve Silberman, who was in Ginsberg’s course in the late ’70’s, and several friends. There is a brief biography of each author behind his/her photograph and, where they are available online, you can navigate to the texts included.
Norton Antivirus Security Flaw Opens Backdoor to Intruders
The flaw, which resides within Symantec’s Norton AntiVirus 2004 application, could let attackers run code of their choice on a user’s system, launch unauthorized pop-ups, or even create a denial-of-service condition to freeze Symantec’s antivirus application. Virus and worm writers are increasingly attempting to disable antivirus and personal firewall security applications, so a flaw such as this would be a prime target for virus writers seeking to disable a user’s defenses.” (Yahoo! News)
A fix is available by running LiveUpdate from your antivirus client on the desktop.
The Case Against Little Green Men
There is. And the reason can be traced to energy efficiency…
As a typical adult, you need at least 2,000 Calories a day. Making the conversion to less arcane units, that works out to about 100 watts of power, 24 hours a day. But remember that if you got your energy through photosynthesis, you would absorb only 8 watts for each square meter of skin. Most of us have about 3 square meters of epidermis, roughly half of which is in shade at any given time (more, if you insist on wearing clothes). So that’s just over a dozen watts of daytime power, nearly 10 times less than our burn rate. To provide the energy for one day’s worth of your gusto-grabbing lifestyle, you’d need to bake on the back patio for three weeks.” (Yahoo! News)
U.S. Denies Report That General Saw Abuse
The Washington Post, in a story first released on its Web site Saturday night, said a military lawyer stated at an open hearing April 2 that Capt. Donald J. Reese told him that Lt. Gen. Ricardo S. Sanchez and other senior military officers were aware of the abuse at the prison.” (Yahoo! News)
Iraq Wedding Film Challenges U.S. on Air Strike
The U.S. military insisted most of the dead were foreign guerrilla fighters who had slipped over the nearby Syrian border. Local people say the Americans massacred wedding guests…
The video is unwelcome news for Washington on a day when it is to present a proposal at the United Nations (news – web sites) seeking approval for its continued military presence in Iraq following a handover of formal sovereignty to an interim government on June 30.
Nor will it help President Bush, who is to make a televised speech to the nation at midnight GMT that will lay out his strategy in Iraq. Bush’s chances of re-election in November have suffered as Americans question the cost of the mission.” (Yahoo! News)
CTIA Plans 411 for Wireless Numbers
Depleted Morality:
DU weaponry is fired by U.S. troops from the Abrams battle tank, A-10 Warthog and other systems. It is pyrophoric, burning spontaneously on impact, and extremely dense, making DU munitions ideal for penetrating an enemy’s tank armor or reinforced bunker. It also is the toxic and radioactive byproduct of enriched uranium, the fissile material in nuclear weapons.” (In These Times [via wood s lot] )
CTIA Plans 411 for Wireless Numbers
Pickin’ and Choosin’, Shuckin’ and Jivin’
I don’t know if people elsewhere in the nation are following the ongoing struggle over gay marriage here in Massachusetts in much detail now that May 17th has come and gone, but needless to say the battle continues. By an overwhelming margin which should be seen as a rebuke to Massachusetts Governor Mitt Romney, the Mass. Senate votes to end 1913 law the governor has been using to prevent out-of-state same sex partners from marrying in the state. It is not clear if the Mass. House will follow suit because of the opposition of conservative, oligarchic (and Catholic) House Speaker Thomas Finneran. The 1913 law, which was designed to prevent interracial marriages, makes it illegal for an out-of-state couple to marry in Mass. if there would be any impediments to their doing so in their home state. Originally, the State Attorney General ruled that Massachusetts would allow marriages between out-of-staters from ten other states which do not specifically define marriage as the union between a man and a woman, but apparently under intense pressure he has reversed himself and said that no gay couples from any of the other forty-nine states could marry here. Town clerks have been ordered to submit records of this week’s marriage license applications to the Governor’s office for scrutiny. The governor’s spokesman says Romney has no choice about the 1913 law because he cannot “pick and choose” which laws he enforces. A friend just sent me a clipping of this interesting rejoinder (which, by the way, is penned by the founder of the venerable Boston Computer Society) in the Boston Globe‘s letters section, which I have not yet been able to find online:
May 21, 2004
AGAIN Eric Fehrnstrom has defended Governor Romney’s overreaching interpretation of the 1913 law banning out of state couples from marrying here with his refrain that “The governor cannot pick and choose which laws to enforce” (“Senate votes to end 1913 law,” Page A1, May 20). It’s time someone called Fehrnstrom on this spurious argument. The fact is, the governor chooses which laws to enforce every day. Massachusetts has a panoply of so-called “blue laws” that have never been enforced in modern times by a Massachusetts governor. These include the law requiring citizens to get written permission from their doctor before taking a bath. The next time Fehrnstrom uses this argument someone should ask if Romney intends to begin enforcing the blue laws as well?
Jonathan Rotenberg, Boston
Can ‘Star Wars: Episode III’ be saved?
Start by firing Lucas, says this opinion piece:
Too political??
A few days ago, I was doing the ego-surfing thing and looking for references to Follow Me Here I hadn’t seen before. I came across an entry by a weblogger who, linking to a FmH post she found praiseworthy, commented that I had redeemed myself as she had just been on the verge of dropping FmH from her blogroll because I was getting “too political.” Well, I plead guilty as charged, your honor. I suppose that, if you are still reading, it is because you do not mind. It was not my intention in starting Follow Me Here to be a political commentator. Cynical me! I fancied myself somehow above national politics and dubious about the relevance to any truly important aspects of life of the actions of the buffoons who choose to dedicate their lives to transparent and ingratiating vote-grubbing and giveaways to their rich friends. Local politics, I have always thought, is a different matter. ‘Think globally, act locally’ makes eminent sense. Nation states the size of the US are just to large and diverse to govern effectively and, seeing that truth, we should divorce ourselves from politics on the irrelevant and absurd national scale, I thought. Perhaps because of that disdain, I have never had the patience to follow the minutia of political machinations, and others on both the left and the right are far more erudite analysts than I aspire to be. Yet, since Bush’s election, the distinction between the merely banal, superficial and pompous and the malignant in politics has come to be clear. While I am not sure that national leadership can make much of a positive difference, it is clear how much evil it can do in the wrong hands. The most important fact in my experience of American public life has come to be not merely, as it is characterized, a ‘culture war’ around which sitcoms we choose to watch, which books move us, or which beverages we drink, but a life-and-death struggle for our souls between the life-affirming and just and the apocalyptic world-destroying (and, believe me, I am the first to get sick to my stomach of hyperbolic prose).
Not to suggest that those of you who do not have children should not be similarly moved, but watching my children grow up in the world George Bush has engendered is to a large extent what has transformed my sense of urgency around political issues. In my professional life as a physician, I fight to make small contributions to maintaining the life-affirming and dignifying effects of healthcare treatment in the face of its debasement. My weblog is becoming my little contribution to a similar but broader, multi-faceted struggle, over the outcome of which I am desperate and far far from confident, to pass on a world that is perhaps just abit more than debased, degraded and totally degenerate to our descendants. I do preach to the choir, but I hope there is something that deepens and widens your perspective and moves you toward further or more nuanced engagement in that struggle. I am logging essentially what widens and deepens my thinking and engagement. I was far more honored by a journalist reader’s recent comment to me that I am doing a good job on the war than I am troubled by those who might want to keep the blinders over their eyes. I hope that, if FmH is “too political” for you, it is because you have already gotten it, that you find all the thoughts upon which I harp already obvious and tedious. In any case, departing reader, fare ye well, and keep up the good fight.
Related: “Despite the worst foreign policy blunder in American history, George W. Bush and his millionaire supporters don’t know the meaning of the word shame”. Hal Crowther writes a devastating impeachment on indyweek.com:
“I never imagined 2004. It would be sophomoric to say that there was never a worse year to be an American. My own memory preserves the dread summer of 1968. My parents suffered the consequences of 1941 and 1929, and my grandfather Jack Allen, who lived through all those dark years, might have added 1918, with the flu epidemic and the Great War in France that each failed, very narrowly, to kill him. Drop back another generation or two and we encounter 1861…
The irreducible truth is that the invasion of Iraq was the worst blunder, the most staggering miscarriage of judgment, the most fateful, egregious, deceitful abuse of power in the history of American foreign policy. If you don’t believe it yet, just keep watching. Apologists strain to dismiss parallels with Vietnam, but the similarities are stunning. In every action our soldiers kill innocent civilians, and in every other action apparent innocents kill our soldiers–and there’s never any way to sort them out. And now these acts of subhuman sadism, these little My Lais.
Since the defining moment of the Bush presidency, the preposterous flight-suit, Fox News-produced photo-op on the Abraham Lincoln in front of the banner that read “Mission Accomplished,” the shaming truth is that everything has gone wrong. Just as it was bound to go wrong, as many of us predicted it would go wrong–if anything more hopelessly wrong than any of us would have dared to prophesy. Iraq is an epic train wreck, and there’s not a single American citizen who’s going to walk away unscathed.”
George Bush never looked into Nick’s eyes
“Even more than the murderers who took my son’s life, I condemn those who make policies to end lives ” — Michael Berg (Guardian.UK)
Cosmos ‘a billion years older’ and far larger than thought
Measurements made in an underground laboratory suggest an atomic reaction that produces energy inside stars is slower than was believed.
It means that estimates of stellar lifetimes are too short. A readjustment gives the Universe an age of 14.7 instead of 13.7 billion years.” (BBC)
Microwave mismatch proves our cosmos is a whopper. “There is not much room left for a small universe”, says a cosmologist, perhaps intending the pun, in response to new research throwing out suggestions that the universe could be a relatively small shape wrapped around itself. At a minimum, the universe is 78 billion light years across. (Nature)
Cannabis Use Not Linked with Psychosocial Harm
‘Currently, there is no strong evidence that use of cannabis of itself causes psychological or social problems,’ such as mental illness or school failure, lead study author Dr. John Macleod of the University of Birmingham in the UK told Reuters Health.
‘There is a great deal of evidence that cannabis use is associated with these things, but this association could have several explanations,’ he said, citing factors such as adversity in early life, which may itself be associated with cannabis use and psychosocial problems.
Macleod and his team reviewed 48 long-term studies, 16 of which provided the highest quality information about the association between illicit drug use reported by people 25 years old or younger and later psychological or social problems. Most of the drug-specific results involved cannabis use.
One consistent finding among the studies was that young people who reported using cannabis were more likely to have attained a lower educational level than their non-cannabis using peers. Cannabis users were also more likely to report an increased use of other illicit drugs.
On the other hand, cannabis use was not consistently associated with violent or antisocial behavior, or with psychological problems.” (Reuters)
The Rebirth of the ‘NYRB’
The firepower it directed against the liberal hawks reveals much about the Review’s political mood these days. Like many in the liberal hawk camp, the publication sanctioned US military intervention in the Balkans on humanitarian grounds. But when Ignatieff & Co. invoked the logic of humanitarian intervention as a basis for military action against Saddam Hussein, the Review (which has showcased Ignatieff’s work for years) insisted that Bush’s crusade against Iraq was something closer to old-fashioned imperialism. As Ian Buruma wrote in a quietly devastating assessment of Paul Berman’s 2003 book Terror and Liberalism: ‘There is something in the tone of Berman’s polemic that reminds me of the quiet American in Graham Greene’s novel, the man of principle who causes mayhem, without quite realizing why.’
What blew the dust off The New York Review? In no sense, really, has the paper returned to its New Left sensibility of the late 1960s: Chomsky, Hayden and Willis have not been reinstated; young lions like The Baffler’s Tom Frank and The Village Voice’s Rick Perlstein have not been invited to contribute; Eric Foner, Bruce Cumings, Richard Rorty, Chalmers Johnson, Stephen Holmes, Anatol Lieven, Elaine Showalter and Carol Brightman continue to publish much of their finest work not in The New York Review of Books but in the more radical, eccentric and sprightly pages of the London Review of Books. In short, the Review’s liberal (and establishment) soul remains intact. What has changed significantly, in the age of Bush, is the Review’s style of rhetoric and degree of political focus and commitment.” (The Nation)
FCC Asked To Examine A la Carte Cable TV
Are You a Potential Terrorist?
The “high terrorism factor” scoring system also became a key selling point for the involvement of the database company, Seisint Inc., in the Matrix project.’ (Wired)
Bush Visits Capitol Hill to Calm Republicans on Major Issues
Is there a Republican in the Senate or the House who is still credulous enough to believe this??
Why We Have to Look
That’s why the beheading footage didn’t enrage me. I expect that sort of thing from a ruthless enemy like Al Qaeda. As a gay American Jew, I know exactly what they have in mind for me. But the images from Abu Ghraib revealed something I hadn’t wanted to confront. It was the real-world manifestation of the snarl-behind-the-smile that Rummy wears so well. Thanks to those leaked photos, we’re closer to understanding why most of the world reads this leer as the look on America’s face.
Pictures of the unfathomable force us to see. That’s why all the evidence of prisoner torture must be released.” — Richard Goldstein, Executive Editor of the Village Voice
"If they killed foreign fighters, why don’t they show us the bodies?"
So potentially damaging is the video to the US occupation that American officials have demanded that the Dubai-based al-Arabiya television news network, which obtained the footage, give them the name of the cameraman who took it. Al-Arabiya has refused.” (Independent.UK )
Also: ‘US Soldiers Started to Shoot Us, One by One’: Survivors describe wedding massacre as generals refuse to apologize. (CommonDreams)
Torture Scandal Deepens, Widens
New front in Iraq detainee abuse scandal?
“With attention focused on the seven soldiers charged with abuse at the Abu Ghraib prison, U.S. military and intelligence officials familiar with the situation tell NBC News the Army’s elite Delta Force is now the subject of a Pentagon inspector general investigation into abuse against detainees. The target is a top-secret site near Baghdad’s airport.” (MSNBC)
Exporting Abuse?
Wardens Chosen to Establish Iraq Prison System Had Past Abuse Allegations.
“A number of former state prison commissioners chosen by the Bush administration to establish a prison system in Iraq left their old posts after allegations of neglect, brutality and inmate deaths, an investigation by ABCNEWS has found.”
“Some prisoners at Iraq’s Abu Ghraib prison were ridden like animals, fondled by female soldiers, forced to curse their religion and required to retrieve their food from toilets, according to a published report Friday.” (Associated Press )
GI: Iraqi boy mistreated to get dad to talk:
“A military intelligence analyst who recently completed duty at Abu Ghraib prison in Iraq (news – web sites) said Wednesday that the 16-year-old son of a detainee there was abused by U.S. soldiers to break his father’s resistance to interrogators.” (Yahoo! News)
Reuters, NBC Staff Abused by U.S. Troops in Iraq
“U.S. forces beat three Iraqis working for Reuters and subjected them to sexual and religious taunts and humiliation during their detention last January in a military camp near Falluja, the three said on Tuesday.
The three first told Reuters of the ordeal after their release but only decided to make it public when the U.S. military said there was no evidence they had been abused, and following the exposure of similar mistreatment of detainees at Abu Ghraib prison near Baghdad.
An Iraqi journalist working for U.S. network NBC, who was arrested with the Reuters staff, also said he had been beaten and mistreated, NBC said on Tuesday.”
Shocking Details on Abuse of Reuters Staffers in Iraq (Editor & Publisher)
‘House Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi on Thursday sharply questioned President Bush’s competence as a leader, suggesting his policy in Iraq is to blame for the loss of U.S. lives. That assessment drew a furious response by Republicans who called on the Democratic leader to apologize.
“The emperor has no clothes,” Pelosi, D-California, told reporters on Thursday. “When are people going to face the reality? Pull this curtain back.” ‘ (CNN )
"…It should come as no surprise… that our chimpanzeeness overcomes and dominates our humanness with regularity…"
Human beings are literally designed to “regress” down the triune brain with ease, but “progressing” up is unnatural, difficult, and requires years of cultural shaping and formal education in industrialized societies. Simply speaking, when regressive processes are set against progressive ones, regression tends to win. Partying tends to win out over studying, impulsivity over self-control, amorality over morality, and disorder over order. Human Paleopsychogy focuses on individual and social breakdowns of cultural, moral, religious, and economic systems that have taken thousands of years to reach their present form. Yet, with the slightest provocation in the form of social malaise, insult, drug or alcohol intake, exposure to pornography, or even sudden changes in the stock market, we see that good will, manners and civility, social order, and concern with “higher things” can disappear in an instant.
The process whereby this occurs is termed phylogenetic regression and it refers to the sudden stripping away of the thin veneer of culture and the complementary re-activation of ancient evolved programs of selfishness, tribality and xenophobia, aggression, sexuality, and the like. In other words, when highly stressed and/or provoked, a person easily slips back into earlier evolutionarily adaptive programs that may have served our ancestors well in precultural times but may be amoral/immoral, socially chaotic, illegal, and even pathological today. For example, sexual promiscuity and male gang behavior in hunting contexts may have served young men well 30,000 years ago, but activation of these tendencies today in the absence of moral, religious, legal, or other constraints can easily lead to rape, gang warfare, or even worst case scenarios like the “inexplicable” murderous actions of the two young men in Littleton, Colorado on April 20, 1999. Human paleopsychology tries to make sense of these “inexplicable” events and others including serial murder involving cannibalism, body mutilation, and storage of body parts, mothers brutally killing their infants and young children, and even phenemona such as rage killing, road rage, and the brutal initiation ritual of the Glenbrook North High School sorority girls who literally outdid their chimpanzee cousins in chaotic violence.” — Kent Bailey (professor emeritus of clinical psychology at Virginia Commonwealth University in Richmond, Virginia)
Tunes are music for the ears and soul
The Moral Levitation of David Brooks
“Real autonomy, real freedom, requires the chooser be somehow suspended, isolated from the push and pull of…causes, so that when decisions are made, nothing causes them except you!”.
New York Times regular David Brooks expresses this view perfectly, writing in his May 15, 2004 column, “Columbine: Parents of a Killer,” that
“My instinct is that Dylan Klebold was a self-initiating moral agent who made his choices and should be condemned for them. Neither his school nor his parents determined his behavior.”
By claiming Klebold was self-initiating, Brooks isolates Klebold from the causal push and pull of school and parents, disconnecting him from the world so that he can count as a “real” moral agent. Brooks seems to think that Klebold’s choices are morally condemnable only if he wasn’t determined to make them. But as Dennett, myself, and others continue to point out, such supernatural moral levitation isn’t in the least necessary to sustain judgments of right and wrong, or to justify holding persons responsible. Causal determinism – being fully caused to be who you are, and do what you do – isn’t a threat to moral agency, although it undermines certain justifications for punishment which Brooks and other conservatives may not want to give up.”
FmH readers will recall I reacted similarly to the Brooks column when it came out, albeit far less eloquently and not couched in the formal language of moral philosophy. Of course, the issue of whether moral agency and causal determinism are opposed informs our purview on the Abu Ghraib torturers as well, as I have tried to suggest in my agonizing over the issue.
give a naturalistic account of ethics. Not just a science-based description of
what we do and think and feel that we ought to do, but in some sense a
justification of these feelings of ought-ness or morality. One way to do this —
a way suggested by the late John Mackie and supported by (among others)
myself — is to argue for some kind of ethical non-realism. We deny that there
are really ethical facts – we argue that, in some sense, a claim like “rape is
wrong” is a fiction (perhaps a very useful fiction) in a way that a claim like
“roses smell nice” is not. Casebeer will have none of this. Arguing from what
he claims is an updated version of the theory of the great Greek philosopher
Aristotle, using the findings of modern evolutionary biology, Casebeer thinks
that he can go all of the way and provide a full-blooded, biology-based — that
is, naturalistic — account of morality.” Human Nature
Barbara Ehrenreich: ‘What Abu Ghraib Taught Me’
Of the seven U.S. soldiers now charged with sickening forms of abuse in Abu Ghraib, three are women: Spc. Megan Ambuhl, Pfc. Lynndie England and Spc. Sabrina Harman.
It was Harman we saw smiling an impish little smile and giving the thumbs-up sign from behind a pile of hooded, naked Iraqi men – as if to say, “Hi Mom, here I am in Abu Ghraib!” It was England we saw with a naked Iraqi man on a leash. If you were doing PR for Al Qaeda, you couldn’t have staged a better picture to galvanize misogynist Islamic fundamentalists around the world.
Here, in these photos from Abu Ghraib, you have everything that the Islamic fundamentalists believe characterizes Western culture, all nicely arranged in one hideous image – imperial arrogance, sexual depravity … and gender equality.” — AlterNet
Placebos effect revealed in calmed brain cells
‘It’s the first time we’ve seen it at the single neuron level,’ says Fabrizio Benedetti, head of the team which conducted the experiments at the University of Turin Medical School in Italy.
When the patients in the study received a simple salt solution, their neurons responded in just the same way as when they had earlier received a drug which eased their symptoms.
‘The research provides further evidence for a physiological underpinning for the placebo effect,’ says Jon Stoessl, at the University of British Columbia in Vancouver, Canada. His team demonstrated in 2001 that placebos can relieve symptoms by raising brain levels of dopamine, a beneficial neurotransmitter.” — New Scientist
This is only surprising to people who still believe in the mind-body dichotomy, of course…
Cosmic dark age found in shadows
The objects have been hidden until now because they formed in the dark age of the universe before the first stars switched on. ‘The shadows promise to provide the richest ever gold mine of information about the early universe,’ says Abraham Loeb of Harvard University.” — New Scientist
Nanobacteria revelations provoke new controversy
“Some claim they are a new life form responsible for a wide-range of diseases, including the calcification of the arteries that afflicts us all as we age. Others say they are simply too small to be living creatures.” New research describes the isolation of miniscule cell-like structures from diseased human arteries, which self-replicated in culture and showed evidence of containing DNA. Furthermore, they seemed to be building RNA, as a mechanism that transcribes code from DNA would do. The controversy provoked by the claims of naonbacteria supporters have been likened to that in physics around cold fusion. Less than 100 nanometers across, the idea that these particles can contain DNA and the proteins needed to function has been ridiculed, and positive findings are ascribed to contaminants. Moreover, they point out, the Finnish researchers promoting the nanobacteria concept have already set up a company to profit from diagnosis and therapy of the supposed disease-causing entities. Both critics and proponents agree that the evidence to data is not probative but only suggestive. — New Scientist
Sway with Me
sway with me, everything sad —
madmen in stone houses
without doors,
lepers steaming love and song
frogs trying to figure
the sky;
sway with me, sad things —
fingers split on a forge
old age like breakfast shell
used books, used people
used flowers, used love
I need you
I need you
I need you:
it has run away
like a horse or a dog,
dead or lost
or unforgiving.
— Charles Bukowski
Homeland Security Eats My Juice?
Why your laptop is always running out of power:
“Another way to provide more power would be to invent a “new chemistry”—a new set of materials with which to build batteries—or to develop a technique for more heavily charging an existing chemistry. But there’s a tradeoff: Generally, the more electricity a battery can store, the more dangerous and toxic it is. Even the lithium-ion battery, a traditionally safe technology, has its own risks. If it were to somehow catch fire, it becomes “exothermic”—it doesn’t need oxygen to burn, so it can’t be smothered. It’ll just burn and burn and burn until there’s nothing left.
This hair-raising prospect means that anyone who wants to build a stronger battery has to deal with federal regulators, most notably the Federal Aviation Administration. If a super-potent battery caught fire on a plane, it could do serious damage to the aircraft. And if it’s a choice between having my laptop conk out after three hours and having a nice powerful battery that knocks the entire plane out of the sky, I’m siding with the FAA. The lithium-ion battery, lame as it can sometimes be, hits the sweet spot between stability and usability. (Computer chips don’t face these problems. When you make them faster, they get hotter, but that isn’t as scary a proposition. You can deal with hot chips by installing better fans, which, of course, require ever more battery power.)
The great hope for the future lies with fuel cells, which are a whole new paradigm for laptop power. When they run out, you don’t recharge them. You just buy new cells and shove ’em in, the same way you put double-As into a portable radio. This year, some companies promise to introduce the first cells. In the long run, they aim to have them widely available for two or three dollars a pop, with each one promising perhaps 15 hours of power.
But fuel cells have their own downside. If they’re made with hydrogen, they produce water as a byproduct, so you’d have to cope with your laptop urinating. And the airlines aren’t too keen about letting people carry hydrogen onboard either, since it can be explosive, too. Manufacturers are looking at making fuel cells safer by using less-potent fuels like ethanol and methanol instead of hydrogen, but they deliver less energy—and the FAA claims they can be a fire hazard, too. In this quest for infinite life there is, as it turns out, no holy grail.” Slate
Pentagon source: "Torture is the only thing you can call this…"
No criminal punishments have been announced in the interrogation deaths, even though three deaths occurred last year.” — Denver Post
A Corrupted Culture
The Washington Post jumps on the bandwagon with this editorial:
This pervasive rot at the core of US military practice in Iraq and elsewhere, the editorial goes on to suggest, arose specifically from Bu**sh**’s decision to take the January 2002 advice of his White House counsel, in a blatant disregard for law and human decency, to ignore State Dept. objections and proceed with his decision to exclude Afghani detainees from the protections of the Geneva Conventions, although it was recognized that this could eventually undermine military conduct. As this policy on prisoner treatment spread to the Iraqi conflict, the president blatantly lied and stated that we were respecting the Geneva Conventions.
I am more than a little impatient with all the soul-searching public debate over just how high up the responsibility for such savage practices goes. A wanton disregard for the law has been the rule in the Bu**sh** administration since the struggle they waged to steal the White House in the first place. Combine that with a grandiose (Salon) and misguided adventurist sense of mission, guided by voices1 (Village Voice), against an enemy we reinvent daily as a self-justification for global war, and it is clear that a pervasive culture of barbarity and deceit (ABC News) is the inevitable outcome.
1“It was an e-mail we weren’t meant to see. Not for our eyes were the notes that showed White House staffers taking two-hour meetings with Christian fundamentalists, where they passed off bogus social science on gay marriage as if it were holy writ and issued fiery warnings that “the Presidents [sic] Administration and current Government is engaged in cultural, economical, and social struggle on every level”—this to a group whose representative in Israel believed herself to have been attacked by witchcraft unleashed by proximity to a volume of Harry Potter. Most of all, apparently, we’re not supposed to know the National Security Council’s top Middle East aide consults with apocalyptic Christians eager to ensure American policy on Israel conforms with their sectarian doomsday scenarios.
But now we know.”
Andy Kaufman — Dead or Alive?
So… did he or did he not reappear on May 16th as promised, twenty years to the day after his ‘death’ ? LA Weekly
Angry at -Gry
‘Verbivore’ Richard Lederer debunks an annoying riddle. This certainly has persistence; it is circulating in my son’s gradeschool, from which he just came home and posed it to me last night.
Who Is Abu Zarqawi?
Profile of the supposed mastermind of the Madrid bombings and Nicholas Berg’s murder by two Nixon Center analysts, whch concludes:
— Weekly Standard
Significant in my reading is that this analysis by conservative anti-terrorist hawks essentially concludes, as I have, that administration claims that he is “al Qaeda-related” are empty rhetoric. Indeed, the entity of “al Qaeda” has no fixed meaning except to western thinkers desperate to have an enemy they can grasp by naming it. Instead, there is a shifting alliance of zealots opportunistically coalescing when their missions conveniently converge.
Google Moves Toward a Direct Confrontation With Microsoft
Google’s software, which is expected to be introduced soon, according to several people with knowledge of the company’s plans, is the clearest indication to date that the company, based in Mountain View, Calif., hopes to extend its search business to compete directly with Microsoft’s control of desktop computing.
Improved technology for searching information stored on a PC will also be a crucial feature of Microsoft’s long-delayed version of its Windows operating system called Longhorn.” — New York Times
Seattle scuplture gets war-themed update
“The figures in Fremont’s ‘Waiting for the Interurban’ sculpture were hooded yesterday, a reference to the recent prison-abuse photos from the war in Iraq.
A witness said the hoods were placed on the statues around noon. A chair next to the sculpture was also wired with jumper cables to look like an implement of torture, and a sign was duct-taped to a statue’s leg announcing weekly peace vigils at Green Lake.” — Seattle Post-Intelligencer
R.I.P. Elvin Jones
The undisputed giant among post-bebop drummers is dead at 76. Jones, who was always an inspiration but rarely emulated (because no one could?), arguably turned the drums singlehandedly from part of the rhythm section to a major improvisational voice in the jazz ensemble, ever since the days when he ‘accompanied’ (rather than just ‘backing’) Coltrane in the ’60’s. Indeed, each of his hands and feet was more like an independent voice of its own. Jones is often cited as a motivation for rock drummers as well, but when you listen to all those interminable plodding drum solos, turn ’em off and go back to Coltrane and Jones. — New York Times
Fizzy drink link to gullet cancer
Good, provocative epidemiology which, as always, raises more questions. A team looking for an explanation for the puzzling and dramatic rise in the incidence of esophageal cancer in the industrialized world suggests that it correlates with the equally alarming rise in the consumption of carbonated beverages, finding that in places like China and Japan where the one hasn’t happened, the other hasn’t either. As always, critics caution that ‘correlation is not causation’ (to use the mantra we are all taught when we learn to decipher research findings). — BBC
The prisoner-abuse scandal at home
No Wizard Left Behind
Harry Potter and Left Behind are more alike than you might think.:
Most obviously, in both cases, we see not a fight between individual good guys and bad guys, but a Manichean struggle between good and evil.”
Steven Waldman, editor in chief of Beliefnet, goes on to compare and contrast. — Slate
What Went Wrong
Christopher Hitchens on what he refers to as the flaws in Seymour Hersh’s theory that bureaucratic and ‘butt-covering’ obstacles which so stymied the Pentagon’s terrorism-fighting tactics engendered frustration that top-level secret policy to apply ruthless methods resulted:
If I understand Hitchens correctly, he does not want so much to dispute Hersh’s analysis as to use its premises to preen and gloat about what he perceives as a devastating inconsistency in the anti-war left’s stance — that it both wanted to hold the Pentagon to the rules of engagement in the WoT® and hold the Pentagon to human rights standards in the detention and interrogation of prisoners-of-war. Where is the inconsistency? Actually, I am using a bit of the same sophistry here as Hitchens does; the real inconsistency he finds is that the left castigates the administration both for its lack of adherence to standards of humanity and for its lack of alacrity and success in capturing terrorist leaders. And for evidence of this he uses… one snide statement by Michael Moore, whose heart may be in the right place but who is surely a sort of loose cannon. Hitchens comes off simpering, and adds to it when he claims that the discovery of the supposed sarin-containing warhead proves there were WMD in Iraq all along.
" Today, Fallouja is for all intents and purposes a rebel town…"
Deadly April Battle Became a Turning Point for Fallouja: Along with the Abu Ghraib revelations, what may come to be seen in the history books as the point where we lost even the semblance of control over or reason for the occupation was the extraordinary news of the US forces turning over control of Fallouja to men who “pull(ed) their old olive-green uniforms and burgundy berets out of the closet and (went) back to work…” The Los Angeles Times dissects the events:
“Privately, Marines who began arriving here in March viewed the Army’s strategy throughout Iraq’s Sunni heartland as unduly confrontational.
But the grisly slayings of four U.S. contractors March 31 changed everything. Orders from a higher authority eclipsed the Marines’ “no better friend” intentions for Fallouja. “When the president says go, we go,” said Col. J.C. Coleman, chief of staff for the 1st Marine Expeditionary Force.
So the Marines were pushed to do something — a full-fledged assault on the city — that the Army had avoided, and military strategists now say was ill-conceived. Too few Marines were marshaled to confront a dug-in urban foe that proved unexpectedly resilient, well-armed and relentless.
The fighting quickly turned ugly, as did the images of dead and maimed civilians and fleeing refugees broadcast on Arab-language television. U.S. forces called a cease-fire after several days. Three weeks later, the insurgents had benefited from the chance to rearm, bring in new recruits and prepare ambushes, ensuring even more slaughter once the battle was renewed.
“In the end, the Americans left themselves with only bad options,” said Michael Clarke, professor of defense studies at King’s College, London. “They could either destroy the city, causing heavy loss of life. Or they could walk away. Both are a disaster, but the Americans chose the less disastrous of the two.””
When Alzheimer’s Steals the Mind, How Aggressively to Treat the Body?
“The question of how aggressive to be in treating late-stage Alzheimer’s patients is one of the most wrenching and contentious issues in medicine. For every patient who, like Mrs. Mull, reaches the final stage of the disease, there typically are about five or six family members faced with decisions about whether to authorize medical treatments for patients whose bodies live on though their minds are gone.” — New York Times
Can Kerry Stay Out Of Bush’s Trap?
“In his first two years as president, George W. Bush set a trap. He pushed through tax cuts so big that they would inevitably force Democrats into a series of no-win arguments during this election year. Democrats could dedicate themselves to undoing the budget damage Bush had caused by favoring tax increases and spending restraint. Or they could ignore the issue of fiscal balance and propose popular programs…
The trap is working marvelously, even if the bad news in Iraq has pushed the budget mess off the front pages. True, competing Democratic factions are so eager to defeat Bush that they are largely holding their tongues. But the party’s deficit hawks and its advocates of new programs are not happy with each other, and both are trying to pull Sen. John Kerry in their direction. Kerry has no choice but to finesse the problem.” —E. J. Dionne Jr., Washington Post op-ed
The Wastrel Son
“He was a stock character in 19th-century fiction: the wastrel son who runs up gambling debts in the belief that his wealthy family, concerned for its prestige, will have no choice but to pay off his creditors. In the novels such characters always come to a bad end. Either they bring ruin to their families, or they eventually find themselves disowned.
George Bush reminds me of those characters — and not just because of his early career, in which friends of the family repeatedly bailed out his failing business ventures. Now that he sits in the White House, he’s still counting on other people to settle his debts — not to protect the reputation of his family, but to protect the reputation of the country.
One by one, our erstwhile allies are disowning us; they don’t want an unstable, anti-Western Iraq any more than we do, but they have concluded that President Bush is incorrigible. Spain has washed its hands of our problems, Italy is edging toward the door, and Britain will join the rush for the exit soon enough, with or without Tony Blair.” — Paul Krugman, New York Times op-ed
Today Should be a National Human Rights Holiday
Not only the fiftieth anniversary of Brown vs. the Board of Education, but Gay Weddings Begin in Massachusetts. New York Times Congratulations to Deb and Jane, friends of mine who are, tonight, finally a ‘happily married couple’!
Fairly Familiar Phrases
Homophones and sound-alikes can often reek — or is it wreck or wreak? — havoc. In each phrase that follows, choose the preferred spelling:
- anchors away/aweigh
- to wait with baited/bated breath
- to grin and bare/bear it
- sound bite/byte
- bloc/block voting
- a ceded/seeded player
- champing/chomping at the bit
- a full complement/compliment of
- to strike a responsive chord/cord
- just deserts/desserts
- doesn’t faze/phase me
- to have a flair/flare for
- foul/fowl weather
- hail/hale and hardy/hearty
- a hair’s/hare’s breadth/breath
- a seamless hole/whole
- a friend in need is a friend in deed/indeed
- to declare it doesn’t jibe/jive
- on the lam/lamb
- to the manner/manor born/borne
- marshal/martial law
- to test one’s medal/meddle/metal/mettle
- might/mite and mane/main
- beyond the pale/pail
- to peak/peek/pique one’s interest
- pi/pie in the sky
- pidgin/pigeon English
- plain/plane geometry
- to pore/pour over an article
- praying/preying mantis
- a matter of principal/principle
- rack/wrack one’s brain
- to give free rain/reign/rein
- raise/raze Cain/cane
- to pay rapped/rapt/wrapped attention
- with reckless/wreckless abandon
- to reek/wreak/wreck havoc
- right/rite of passage
- a shoe-/shoo-in
- to sic/sick the dog on someone
- sleight/slight of hand
- spit and/spitting image
- the old stamping/stomping grounds
- to stanch/staunch the flow
- dire straights/straits
- a toe-/tow-headed youth
- to toe/tow the line
- to swear like a trooper/trouper
- all in vain/vane/vein
- to wet/whet your appetite
Abuse Scandal Rages On
I am pretty much raged out about the prisoner abuse scandal, but it continues to grow, as per my several uses of the phrase “tip of the iceberg” in my posts when the Abu Ghraib news was first revealed. Let’s see; the Solicitor General seems to have lied to the Supreme Court in asserting that we have not mistreated prisoners when defending the administration’s assertion of the right of indefinite detention of US citizens without due process. Guantanamo detainees and prisoners in Afghanistan have been subjected to pretty much the same treatment as those in Iraq, we learn. In a sense, so have American women in the military.
To no thinking person’s surprise, the pattern of abuse apparently emanated from deliberate, secret interrogation policy formulated at the top of the Bu**sh** administration with all due recognition of the vulnerability of Muslim men to sexual humiliation. Easy enough for the dysadministration to dismiss such claims when they are made by Seymour Hersh in that effete rag, The New Yorker; but then you get a crack Newsweek investigative team confirming and amplifying on Hersh’s story. Now the list of dubious details raising suspicions about the Nicholas Berg execution videotape has grown to fifty or more. Given that it is conceivable to many that the Administration is capable of manufacturing this to divert attention from the unpleasant facts emerging from Abu Ghraib, what are we to think of chilling reports that Bush and his cronies are ready — or perhaps we should say eager? — for terrorist attack on US targets in the leadup to the November election.
Blog Readers’ Survey
Here you will find a short blog reader survey; if you type in ‘Follow Me Here’ as the referrer in question 22, I will get back a summary of demographic information about my readers and their preferences, which I will share with you here.
‘Emily, get out of the way.’
Lisa Rein’s weblog has links to the mirrors of streams of Colin Powell’s Meet the Press appearance yesterday in which he rebukes his own press aide for trying to take him off the air early, just as Tim Russert is about to ask a candid question about the Nigerian yellowcake uranium confabulation that was used as evidence of our need to invade Iraq. Powell orders the camera back on and the interview resumed, and acknowledges that the uranium story was deliberately misleading. Is this Powell’s swansong? [via boing boing]
Today Should be a National Human Rights Holiday
Not only the fiftieth anniversary of Brown vs. the Board of Education, but Gay Weddings Begin in Massachusetts. New York Times Congratulations to Deb and Jane, friends of mine who are, tonight, finally a ‘happily married couple’!
US Takes Greenpeace to Court in Unusual Trial
The environmental group is accused of sailor mongering because it boarded a freighter in April 2002 that was carrying illegally felled Amazon mahogany to Miami. It says the prosecution is revenge for its criticism of the environmental policies of President Bush, whom it calls the ‘Toxic Texan.'” — Reuters
‘When did you stop beating your wife?’ Dept:
U.S. bans coercion of Iraqi prisoners / No sleep deprivation or similar methods — ‘We will not even entertain a request’. — San Francisco Chronicle
Powell Says Troops Would Leave Iraq if New Leaders Asked
Paul Bremer hinted at it several days ago, if you could believe al Jazeera. Now, if you can believe the Washington Post:
Conn. Woman Sentenced in Son’s Suicide
Kicking off a somewhat thematically related series of posts:
R.I.P. David Reimer, 38
Subject of the John/Joan Case Dies:
“After a botched circumcision operation when he was a toddler, David Reimer became the subject of a study that became known as the John/Joan case in the 60’s and 70’s. His mother said she was still angry with the Baltimore doctor who persuaded her and her husband, Ron, to give female hormones to their son and raise him as a daughter.
As he grew up as Brenda in Winnipeg, he faced cruelty from the other children. ‘They wouldn’t let him use the boys’ washroom or the girls’,’ Ms. Reimer recalled. ‘He had to go in the back alley.’
His sexual reassignment was then widely reported as a success and proof that children are not by nature feminine or masculine but through nurture are socialized to become girls or boys. David’s identical twin brother, Brian, offered researchers a matched control subject.
But when, as a teenager, he discovered the truth about his past , he resumed his male identity, eventually marrying and becoming a stepfather to three children.” Reimer, despondent about the loss of a job, the breakdown of his marriage, and still grieving the death of his twin brother two years ago, reportedly ended his own life. — New York Times
Parents of a Killer
David Brooks writes, in a New York Times op-ed column,
Klebold’s parents, who gave Brooks access because they “trust their daily paper”, the Times, deemphasize the murders and speak of what their son did as suicide. They blame the ‘toxic culture’ at his school and, describing a moment when somebody said “I forgive you”, Klebold’s mother objects that they did nothing they need to be forgiven for. On the other hand, they can imagine that their son “…suffered horribly before he died. For not seeing that, I will never forgive myself.” But, true to form, the incisive David Brooks simplifies it beautifully for all of us who might be wrestling unproductively with the complexities of such an act and its aftermath:
America Adrift in Iraq
An insipid New York Times editorial illustrates how easy it is, all of a sudden, to be on board with the notion that the Iraqi occupation is a morass only being made worse by our continued presence. However, it steers away from reminders that this outcome was clear from the inception of the war. The Times falls flat on its face around solutions. While holding on to an unquestioning commitment to the fetishistic June 30 “sovereignty” deadline and the continued presence of US forces in Iraq (they suggest we may need even more), they hope the UN will rescue the transition.
Undeterred by McCain Denials, Some See Him as Kerry’s No. 2
The enthusiasm of Democrats for Mr. McCain, an Arizona Republican, is so high that even some who have been mentioned as possible Kerry running mates — including Senator Bill Nelson of Florida and Bob Kerrey, the former Nebraska senator — are spinning scenarios about a “unity government,” effectively giving Mr. Kerry a green light to reach across the political aisle and extend an offer.” — New York Times
Scientists Say Crater Is Result of a Killer Meteor
Pressure to Go Along With Abuse Is Strong, but Some Soldiers Find Strength to Refuse
In numerous studies over the past few decades, psychologists have found that a certain percentage of people simply refuse to give in to pressure — by authorities or by peers — if they feel certain actions are wrong.” — New York Times
Hard to remember in dark times, but important…
‘ It was something like a sort of cabaret version of They Might Be Giants.’
The project began when Michael Hearst of the band One Ring Zero, soon after moving to Manhattan in 2001, sought out a small store he’d heard about that was founded by Dave Eggers, author of A Heartbreaking Work of Staggering Genius. The band was invited to perform at McSweeney’s events and soon met Rick Moody, who invited them to perform and collaborate with him. Thus began a cascade of authors offering to write songs for the band…
Featuring:
Jonathan Ames, Margaret Atwood, Paul Auster, Clay McLeod Chapman,
Dave Eggers, Amy Fusselman, Neil Gaiman, Myla Goldberg, Ben Greenman,
Daniel Handler, A.M. Homes, Denis Johnson, Lawrence Krauser, Jonathan Lethem, Rick Moody, Aaron Naparstek, and Darin Strauss.”
Annals of Big Pharma Abuse (cont’d):
While doctors can prescribe drugs for any use, the promotion of drugs for these so-called “off-label uses” is prohibited by the Food and Drug Cosmetic Act.
Last May, federal prosecutors in Boston filed a brief in support of Franklin’s lawsuit, and have since been in settlement negotiations with New York-based Pfizer to recover money the Medicaid program spent on Neurontin.
Franklin’s lawsuit alleged that the company’s publicity plan included paying doctors to put their names on ghostwritten articles about Neurontin and to induce them to prescribe the drug for various uses by giving them tickets to sporting events, trips to golf resorts and speakers fees. One doctor received almost $308,000 to speak at conferences about the drug.
Neurontin’s sales soared from $97.5 million in 1995 to nearly $2.7 billion in 2003.” — New York Times
What is worth emphasizing is that it is not illegal for MDs to prescribe drugs for off-label uses; it is only illegal for the manufacturer to do any marketing for such purposes. What may have gotten Warner-Lambert (the Pfizer-owned company that pushed Neurontin, whose generic name is gabapentin) in trouble in this case, and netted whistleblowing scientist Franklin more than $26 million himself in the settlement of this lawsuit, is that this is the first anti-epileptic drug developed in the last several decades that does not turn out to have mood-stabilizing properties useful in psychiatric practice; clinical psychiatrists such as myself readily seize upon each newly-introduced anticonvulsant for our own purposes. (There are good scientific reasons to believe that a medicine with the one set of indications will also be effective for the other; in a nutshell, there may be similar physiological instabilities in brain function in at least some mood instability as there are in convulsive conditions.). I used an awful lot of gabapentin with my patients, on the basis of those reasonable assumptions, before my cliical experience and that of my colleagues began to tell me it might not be that useful. (Why did it take so long to figure it out? Because stability is a hard thing to verify except over time…)
I am amazed at Warner-Lambert’s ineptitude in its marketing practices, presumably blinded by the dollar signs in its eyes, in this case. Whenever a drug representative visits me (and I do not let it happen very often, and take no ‘perks’ from them when they do come), I am not interested in learning about the official indications for their products or the research data supporting the medication’s efficacy and tolerability, which is what they want to impart. I learn about medications from reading the peer-reviewed medical journals in my field,not marketing propaganda. I often try to persuade the reps to talk about the off-the-record, experimental, and projected uses of their medications, and 90% of the time they demur, citing FDA guidelines (although they will suggest references in the literature where I can explore these interests.) Maybe they think I’m an FDA ‘ringer’ or ‘narc’, but they usually cannot be trolled in the way Warner-Lambert was seemingly eager to be. By the way, this article is misleading in one sense. Companies do not give doctors speaking fees to induce them to prescribe the drugs; they only hire doctors who are already big users of the drugs (it has long since been the case that the pharnaceutical manufacturers keep a database allowing them to pull up data on every doctor’s prescribing statistics). Hiring a big booster of Neurontin, already in the bag, to do the speaking circuit is a way to get a credible authority to induce their colleagues to prescribe more Neurontin. Putting it more crudely, the doctors doing the speaking tours are the whores, not the johns.
(Footnote: it does turn out that gabapentin is probably useful for a variety of these off-label uses, including chronic headache and other pain conditions.).
A Home Test for Parallel Universes
With the aid of David Deutsch, a physicist at Oxford University and his excellent book The Fabric of Reality, the experiment, in a step-by-step process, is going to be set-up and, then, it’s going to be explained why this magic-like result from this experiment is indeed proof of a parallel universe.” — allsci
I don’t need to try and detect parallel universes; I already live in one. And sometimes I think that, despite its being a parallel universe, I am stuck constantly trying to angle-park…
A hard rain’s a-gonna fall
George Monbiot on the Day After Tomorrow controversy:
Guantánamo abuse same as Abu Ghraib, say Britons
Annals of Clumsy Smokescreens
Glenn Reynolds is very upset that the media are continuing to focus on Abu Ghraib even after the Nicholas Berg execution. He wants to persuade us that Berg is the story we should care about enough to forget the prison scandal. It is only the left wing conspiracy against the Bu**sh** administration that makes for anything different. Oh, and part of the conspiracy was that the Boston Globe deliberately ran faked Abu Ghraib sexual abuse photos and refused to apologize. Most of the article consists of search engine reports that various “Nick Berg” phrases were its most popular search requests this week, not “Abu Ghraib” phrases. Uhhh, could that be because the Abu Ghraib photos were all over the web while the Berg videotape was hard to find? Desperately watching the sands of public opinion sift through your fingers, are you, Glenn?
Berg’s Father and Firm Were On A Right-Wing ‘Enemies’ List
Both father and son cared deeply about Iraq. But they were on opposite sides of opinion on the occupation –though you would never know that from reading the New York Times.
Michael was ardently antiwar, whereas his Bush-supporting son was in favor of the war to the extent that he had already visited Iraq seeking to help with rebuilding efforts.” — Break for News
FreeRepublic.com: “A Conservative News Forum” — “Here you are, FReepers. Here is the enemy.”
Bremer hints at US pullout from Iraq
‘I don’t think that will happen but obviously we don’t stay in countries where we’re not welcome,’ he said at a working lunch in Baghdad with Iraqi officials from Diyala province.” — Aljazeera.net

