The Redirection

//www.threeriversonline.com/56147511_f7ad2a129b.jpg' cannot be displayed]Seymour Hersh’s new New Yorker piece details the ways that, as our Iraq policy has gone all to hell and the dysadministration has turned more to destabilizing Iran, we end up finding common cause with some of our so-called enemies in the Twat ® (“the war against terror”). The New Yorker, helpfully, links to all of Hersh’s Iran pieces, which make interesting sequential reading:

  • The Coming Wars (1/24/05): “What the Pentagon can now do in secret.”
  • The Iran Plans (4/17/06): “Would President Bush go to war to stop Tehran from getting the bomb?”
  • Last Stand (7/10/06): “The military’s problem with the President’s Iran policy.”
  • The Next Act (11/27/06): “Is a damaged Administration less likely to attack Iran, or more?”
Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged

US generals ‘will quit’ if Bush orders Iran attack

“Some of America’s most senior military commanders are prepared to resign if the White House orders a military strike against Iran, according to highly placed defence and intelligence sources. Tension in the Gulf region has raised fears that an attack on Iran is becoming increasingly likely before President George Bush leaves office. The Sunday Times has learnt that up to five generals and admirals are willing to resign rather than approve what they consider would be a reckless attack.” (Sunday Times of London)

Highly placed military officers would of course be sacked if they made that sentiment public… unless an unassailable number of them did it at the same time. My guess is that there would be considerably more than five that way…

US generals ‘will quit’ if Bush orders Iran attack

“Some of America’s most senior military commanders are prepared to resign if the White House orders a military strike against Iran, according to highly placed defence and intelligence sources. Tension in the Gulf region has raised fears that an attack on Iran is becoming increasingly likely before President George Bush leaves office. The Sunday Times has learnt that up to five generals and admirals are willing to resign rather than approve what they consider would be a reckless attack.” (Sunday Times of London)

Highly placed military officers would of course be sacked if they made that sentiment public… unless an unassailable number of them did it at the same time. My guess is that there would be considerably more than five that way…

Here comes Newt

Dick Morris: “Newt, consigned by many observers to Elizabeth Dole or Dan Quayle status in this GOP nominating process, appears to be moving up into contention, overtaking former Massachusetts Gov. Mitt Romney and battling to be the conservative alternative to either former New York Mayor Rudy Giuliani or Arizona Sen. John McCain. ” (The Hill)

Last of the True Believers

“Even if Congress moves next to fiddle with funding the war, [Bush] might just have the upper hand.

History is on the president’s side. Even in unpopular wars, Congress has failed to sustain major efforts to control the purse strings. As unpopular as the Vietnam War was, Congress never cut funding while U.S. troops were on the ground in Indochina.

While tolerating the right of lawmakers to “express their opinion” in a resolution, Bush is signaling that a fierce fight awaits those who aim to cut war funds. For starters, he will not shy away from accusing Congress of abandoning the troops, no matter how clever Democratic leaders might be in crafting measures that undercut Bush policy without restricting the flow of resources for troops on the ground.” (CQ)

Hell hath no fury like Hillary

Toby Harnden: “A delicious spat between the Obama and Hillary camps today after coruscating anti-Clinton comments from Hollywood mogul David Geffen that vividly encapsulated every concern about Hillary and Bill that nestles in the hearts of Democrats wary of the couple.

What did it reveal? That this will be a bloody campaign. That Team Obama is prepared to do battle. That Team Clinton wants to bury Obama early. And that Hillary will respond to every slight with ferocious indignation while protesting with a straight face that she only wants to run a positive campaign.

Geffen’s comments to Maureen Dowd of the New York Times were incredibly damaging to Hillary. Dowd is one of the most influential political journalists in the US. Two decades ago, she sunk the presidential campaign of Joe Biden. Hillary wants to make sure Maureen doesn’t do the same thing to her.” (Telegraph.UK)

Geffen’s major misgivings speak to the unelectability of Clinton and the vulnerability to giving the election easily to the Republicans if she is the nominee.

Emotional Decisions

“Emotions are ordinarily conceived as irrational occurrences that cloud judgment and distort reasoning. This view is well entrenched, despite work in both philosophy and psychology that establishes a strong connection between emotion and cognition. During recent years there has been an explosion of research which indicates that rather than being natural adversaries, rational and emotional processes function together. Barnes and Thagard (in press) argue that emotions and inferences are both necessary when we empathize with other people. Social psychologists have explored the function of emotions in social perception and judgment (Forgas, 1991). But the interdependence of emotional and cognitive processes is perhaps most powerfully presented in recent neurobiological studies which establish that emotion is indispensable in rational decision making.” (— Barnes and Thagard)

Some sweet news

“Scientists funded in part by the Mars Inc. candy company delivered the not-unwelcome news Sunday morning during what was described as the first systematic review of chocolate’s effects on learning and memory.

A two-hour symposium on the neurobiology of chocolate, billed as a potentially ‘mind-altering experience,’ drew a standing-room-only crowd during the annual meeting in San Francisco of the American Association for the Advancement of Science.

Five years ago, a similar meeting popularized evidence suggesting that flavanols, a chemical found in the beans from which chocolate is made, have beneficial effects on cardiovascular health.

Now it seems chocolate might do even more.” `(San Francisco Chronicle)

With One Word, Children’s Book Sets Off Uproar

A Newbery-winning book has been banned from some school libraries around the country.: “The word “scrotum” does not often appear in polite conversation. Or children’s literature, for that matter.Yet there it is on the first page of The Higher Power of Lucky, by Susan Patron, this year’s winner of the Newbery Medal, the most prestigious award in children’s literature. The book’s heroine, a scrappy 10-year-old orphan named Lucky Trimble, hears the word through a hole in a wall when another character says he saw a rattlesnake bite his dog, Roy, on the scrotum.” (New York Times )

With One Word, Children’s Book Sets Off Uproar

A Newbery-winning book has been banned from some school libraries around the country.: “The word “scrotum” does not often appear in polite conversation. Or children’s literature, for that matter.Yet there it is on the first page of The Higher Power of Lucky, by Susan Patron, this year’s winner of the Newbery Medal, the most prestigious award in children’s literature. The book’s heroine, a scrappy 10-year-old orphan named Lucky Trimble, hears the word through a hole in a wall when another character says he saw a rattlesnake bite his dog, Roy, on the scrotum.” (New York Times )

25-million year-old frog?

//d.yimg.com/us.yimg.com/p/ap/20070216/capt.afd8ddf5d20c49d79f51acefedb7520a.mexico_frog_in_amber_mo101.jpg?x=380&y=245&sig=fzVsuShsfWsXObgkEBzTag--' cannot be displayed]

“In this photo released by the Institute of Natural History and Ecology of the state of Chiapas, a chunk of amber containing an almost one-centimeter (0.4-inch) frog that was recently discovered by a miner in the southern state of Chiapas, Mexico, Feb. 16, 2007. If authenticated, researchers believe that the frog could have been preserved in the amber for 25 million years.”

"Umpteen" Denials = "Doth Protest too Much?"

Defense Chief Again Says U.S. Will Not Wage War With Iran: “Defense Secretary Robert M. Gates said Thursday that the United States had no intention of attacking Iran and that any American military efforts against it would be confined to Iraq to disrupt the smuggling of bomb-making materials over the border.

‘For the umpteenth time, we are not looking for an excuse to go to war with Iran,’ he said at a Pentagon news conference. ‘We are not planning a war with Iran.’ ” (New York Times )

How Lilly sells Zyprexa

In an installment of Slate‘s “Hot Documents” series, a 2001 memo from Lilly’s marketing department lays out the battle plan for marketing the antipsychotic medication Zyprexa (Lilly’s brand of olanzapine). It is commonplace to observe that the health of the American people is hostage to Big Pharma these days; several important aspects of just how this has been brought about are highlighted here.

The major therapeutic advances in psychopharmacology during my professional career in psychiatry have been the development of new types of two classes of medications, antidepressants and antipsychotics, the rationale for developing which has been the notion that they are less prone to cause side effects than older antidepressants or antipsychotics, and thus far more tolerable and less complicated for our patients to take. Eli Lilly has been at the forefront of these developments with its products Prozac (fluoxetine), the first of the SSRI antidepressants, and Zyprexa (olanzapine), one of the first two new-generation “atypical” antipsychotics.

I have long ranted about prescribing trends in psychiatric medications which follow from these developments. The vast expansion in prescribing of these classes of drugs, often for inappropriate or marginal indications, and decreasing intensity of followup and supervision of their use, leads to rampant problems. These have included the highly-publicized seeming association between antidepressant prescribing and suicidality and (to a lesser extent) incidents of violence and rage; the discomfort associated with discontinuing antidepressants too rapidly; and, as the current article highlights, the epidemic of serious and supposedly unanticipated metabolic complications emerging with the use of the atypical antipsychotic medications.

A more pervasive and perhaps more serious complication than these has been the changing message we are giving our patients — that reaching for the prescription pad can replace the careful crafting of a relationship with an afflicted individual that allows them to come to grips with their life problems; that people do not need to be seen as individuals but rather merely instances of a diagnostic class; that an external agent (a doctor; a medication) can fix them with little effort on their part; that they are passive witnesses rather than active agents in their recovery and, by extension, in their lives; that there is less and less room for personal responsibility in life; that there is little value to careful diagnosis and little distinction between diseases requiring treatment and “cosmetic” personality variants one must either accept or modify slowly and painstakingly.

The leaked memo confirms what I have assumed — that Big Pharma has had deliberate and explicit strategies to persuade less qualified practitioners to prescribe these medications; to prescribe them with less care and supervision; to prescribe them for a broader range of conditions for which they are less appropriate; and to disregard the serious complications they can cause.

All of these, of course, have one goal and one goal only — to maximize profit and commodify already horribly disenfranchised patients with mental health problems. And, when the medications rather than the marketing practices are blamed for the complications and adverse outcomes that follow, mental health treatment is vilified, psychiatric illnesses further stigmatized, and suffering individuals dissuaded from seeking appropriate care that could alleviate their serious distress.

Must know terms for today’s intelligentsia

…”[A] startling number of so-called ‘intellectuals’ remain grossly ignorant of pending technologies and the revealing sciences (the postmodernists immediately come to mind). Today’s intelligentsia, in order to qualify for such a designation, must have the requisite vocabulary with which to address valid social concerns and effectively assess the future.

Here is a list of must-know terms (there are many, many more, but these are IMO the most critical and fundamental)…” (Sentient Developments)

Extra Senses

“Aristotle defined our five senses over two and a half thousand years ago. But in fact we have many more. In this five part series, Graham Easton delves into the Extra Senses that we take for granted. He finds out how they work and meets some remarkable people who experience these senses in a unique way.” (BBC – Radio 4)

Time Travelers: Lay Off Grandpas

“You know what’s getting really tedious? All these time travelers. It seems like two weeks don’t go by without some jerk with a time belt and a bad attitude blinking into my living room and trying to zap me into molecules, usually right in the middle of House. Some of them are members of something called ‘The Chrono-Police,’ some are plucky adventurers from the 30th century, and one of them was a crazy scientist/inventor from 2035 who tried to brain me with a bust of President Clinton-Bush.” — Lore Sjoberg (Wired News)

R.I.P. Ivan Boszormenyi-Nagy

//www.systemagazin.de/efta2004/Fotos/nagy.jpg' cannot be displayed]

Innovator of Family Therapy Dies at 86: “Dr. Ivan Boszormenyi-Nagy, a psychiatrist who helped establish a powerful therapy for mental illness that brings patients’ extended families into treatment as allies, died Jan. 28 at his home in Glenside, Pa. He was 86.

The cause was complications of Parkinson’s disease, said his wife, Dr. Catherine Ducommun-Nagy, also a psychiatrist.

Dr. Nagy (pronounced nahj), as he was known, was one of several therapists, including Murray Bowen and Lyman C. Wynne, who in the 1950s and 1960s began to look beyond individual psychology to understand and try to treat severe mental disorders, particularly schizophrenia. (Dr. Wynne died on Jan. 17.)

Dr. Nagy noticed that destructive patterns of family interaction often spanned generations. To address them, he brought patients’ grandparents and children into therapy sessions, if possible, as well as parents and siblings. He found that by working to balance loyalties and ethical obligations among family members, he could help soothe patients’ symptoms, if not always cure them.

This work became the foundation for six books and some 80 articles, many of which have been read widely in translation in Europe and elsewhere. One of his most influential books, Invisible Loyalties (Harper & Row, 1973), written with Geraldine M. Spark, inspired a generation of therapists to think more broadly about mental health as part of a family system, dependent on hidden loyalties and commitments.” (New York Times )

During the last generation, we have seen the waning influence of extended family in American social structure. This might have made Nagy’s therapeutic techniques passé. However, what is more enduring and appealing has been his introduction of the notion of ethical obligations and commitments in family life. Talking about fairness and unfairness is a very experience-near way of addressing some of the distress people feel in families, and it is certainly amplified, and inherently more difficult to talk about, when one of them has a major mental illness. Nagy’s powerful therapeutic techniques never had the notoriety or sex appeal of those of some of his more flamboyant or photogenic colleagues, but he will be missed by many thoughtful therapists who treat the family context.

Afternoon nap may lower heart disease risk

“Taking midday naps often may significantly reduce the risk of death from coronary heart disease, according to a new study by researchers from the Harvard School of Public Health (HSPH) and the University of Athens Medical School (UAMS) in Greece.

Subjects who took a nap regardless of the frequency and duration were one third less likely to die from heart attack or stroke than those who did not, the researchers reported in the February 12, 2007 issue of The Archives of Internal Medicine.

But some experts quickly warned that people should not rely on taking a nap to reduce their risk of heart disease…” (foodconsumer.org)

I am not sure if the napping is the independent variable here. It may be that people who take naps take better care of themselves in general, are less driven and more relaxed, etc. Correlation is not causation.

Pace says he hasn’t seen evidence of Iranian meddling

“A day after the U.S. military charged Iran’s government with shipping powerful explosive devices to Shiite Muslim fighters in Iraq to use against American troops, the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff said Monday that he hasn’t seen any intelligence to support the claim.” (San Jose Mercury News)

It is incredible that the dysadministration be allowed to get away with this yet again. First of all, the proportion of the IED-related casualties arising from the supposedly-Iranian devices is miniscule. Secondly, even if the devices in question originate in Iran, there is no evidence that Iranians have brought them into Iraq or that their use is state-sponsored. They may just as well have been bought on the black market. And wouldn’t it be in the interests of at least some of the Iraqi insurgents to turn the US’ attention in the direction of Iranian meddling? Encouraging the extension of armed conflict to Iran would further diffuse American power, bog us down even more severely and create the opportunity for a humiliating American defeat an even more humiliating American defeat than we are undergoing now.

March 3, 2007, Lunar Eclipse

//science.nasa.gov/headlines/y2007/images/lunareclipse/Murray1.jpg' cannot be displayed]
“The next eclipse is right around the corner: Saturday, March 3, 2007… The phenomenon will be visible from parts of all seven continents including the eastern half of North America. In the USA, the eclipse will already be underway when the moon rises on Saturday evening. Observing tip: Find a place with a clear view of the eastern horizon and station yourself there at sunset. As the sun goes down behind you, a red moon will rise before your eyes. Rising moons are often reddened by clouds or pollution, but this moon will be the deep, extraordinary red only seen during a lunar eclipse.” (NASA )

Here, There and Everywhere

“I am an American consumer, and the battle to catch the corner of my eye is growing more desperate by the hour. Desperate and counterproductive, it now seems clear. We all know what happened in Boston the other week, when the guerrilla marketing of a cartoon series triggered a grand mal metro seizure, but only I know what happened in Los Angeles several days earlier. I was standing in an airport security line when I spotted an advertisement for Rolodexes printed across the bottom of the tub into which I was about to set my shoes. The ad bewildered me for a couple of reasons. First, I didn’t expect to see it there (even though, by now, I should have, since researchers estimate that the average city dweller is exposed to 5,000 ads per day, up from 2,000 per day three decades ago). The second and greater mystery, however, was why a major company would want me to associate its product with the experience of being searched. Rolodex — the official corporate sponsor of airport paranoia. It didn’t make sense.” — Walter Kirn (New York Times)

Bill Maher: a lesson in Smith death

Maher cuts through the media circus: “‘If you want to find something in this that’s meaningful, it’s a good time to make the point that people in this country die from prescription drugs, I think that’s what it was. I think that when you’re 39 years old and you turn up dead … it’s probably because of drugs. In this country, as long as your name is on the little bottle, you’re cool. Marijuana has been tested exhaustively over the last 30 years–just by me. I don’t remember anybody ever dying from that. But that’s illegal, and whatever she was doing is cool because it’s a pharmaceutical drug.'” (Chicago Tribune)

About That Mean Streak of Yours:

Psychiatry Can Do Only So Much: “On the other hand, maybe he was mean by nature, a concept that may sound heretical coming from a psychiatrist because it seems dangerously close to rendering a moral judgment on a patient’s soul, something doctors should doubtless leave to theologians and philosophers.

But if some people turn out happy and good despite a lifetime of withering hardships, why can’t some people be mean or bad for no discernible reason?

There can be a relationship between nastiness and mental illness, and many therapists assume that when patients are mentally ill and mean, the illness is probably the cause of the ill temper.

But human meanness is far more common than all the mental illness in the population combined, so the contribution of mental illness to this essential human trait must be very small indeed.” — Richard Friedman MD (New York Times )

This is one in my continuing series of posts objecting to the medicalization of everyday life, which is particularly rampant in the mental health field. Psychiatrists are taught, as the writer above alludes to, to avoid passing moral judgment on others’ souls, but what if the only other way to validate your perceptions of or reactions to the way someone does business with you is to diagnose them with a disorder?

One of my particular interests in my work is the treatment of irritability and interpersonal violence, some of which is attributable to personality disorders and some to brain pathologies. Some, but not most…

The duty of the psychiatrist is as much to know when not to treat as to treat. We have to be very careful not to contribute to the epidemic of erosion of personal responsibility for behavior in modern society. Giving someone a diagnosis can serve to let them “off the hook”; this is a relief and a service when it is appropriate but a travesty when it is not, as it often is not. How many times have I heard a patient say, “I can’t help it. They tell me I’ve got a chemical imbalance” or the like?

An essay such as Friedman’s is a bold affront to a worrisome facet of the medical status quo, to be heartily welcomed from one curmudgeon to another.

Bill Maher: a lesson in Smith death

Maher cuts through the media circus: “‘If you want to find something in this that’s meaningful, it’s a good time to make the point that people in this country die from prescription drugs, I think that’s what it was. I think that when you’re 39 years old and you turn up dead … it’s probably because of drugs. In this country, as long as your name is on the little bottle, you’re cool. Marijuana has been tested exhaustively over the last 30 years–just by me. I don’t remember anybody ever dying from that. But that’s illegal, and whatever she was doing is cool because it’s a pharmaceutical drug.'” (Chicago Tribune)

A Princeton Lab on ESP Plans to Close Its Doors

‘Over almost three decades, a small laboratory at Princeton University managed to embarrass university administrators, outrage Nobel laureates, entice the support of philanthropists and make headlines around the world with its efforts to prove that thoughts can alter the course of events. But at the end of the month, the Princeton Engineering Anomalies Research laboratory, or PEAR, will close, not because of controversy but because, its founder says, it is time.

…”For 28 years, we’ve done what we wanted to do, and there’s no reason to stay and generate more of the same data,” said the laboratory’s founder, Robert G. Jahn, 76, former dean of Princeton’s engineering school and an emeritus professor. “If people don’t believe us after all the results we’ve produced, then they never will.” ‘ (New York Times )

The Unseen and Unexplained, Inching Closer to the Truth

“Anyone who thinks it’s a good sign that Lost is back has not spent enough time at the Web site of James Randi, a skeptical scholar of the pseudoscientific and the supernatural.

A fan recently posed this question online at randi.org: “Is a fascination and increased belief in the supernatural a sign of social decline?” The answer came as categorically as the words under the Magic 8-Ball: “Yes. Absolutely.”

By itself, Lost may not be a harbinger of the decline of Western civilization. But alongside Heroes, as well as Medium, Ghost Whisperer and Raines, a new NBC drama that begins in March and stars Jeff Goldblum as a detective who solves murders by appearing to commune with dead victims, the collapse looks pretty darn nigh.

Lost… is the most intriguing of all the series that traffic in the supernatural, mostly because it defies its own illogical reasoning…” (New York Times )

Point well-taken, but shouldn’t we be hearkening at least as far back as The X-Files and Millennium, if not Twilight Zone and Kolchak, with such concerns?

Koreans Share Their Secret for Chicken With a Crunch

Koreans Share Their Secret for Chicken With a Crunch – New York Times: “Many Asian cooking traditions include deep-fried chicken, but the popular cult of crunchy, spicy, perfectly nongreasy chicken — the apotheosis of the Korean style — is a recent development.

In the New York area, Korean-style fried chicken places have just begun to appear, reproducing the delicate crust, addictive seasoning and moist meat Koreans are devoted to.” (New York Times )

I am addicted to this stuff (although never a lover of American Southern fried chicken…).

Wash. Proposal Would Annul Childless Marriages

After three childless years, marriages would be unrecognized and partners ineligible for marital benefits: ““For many years, social conservatives have claimed that marriage exists solely for the purpose of procreation … The time has come for these conservatives to be dosed with their own medicine,’ said WA-DOMA organizer Gregory Gadow in a printed statement. “If same-sex couples should be barred from marriage because they can not have children together, it follows that all couples who cannot or will not have children together should equally be barred from marriage.'” (NWCN via walker)

Watada’s Court-Martial Ends in Mistrial

The Army lieutenant who refused to deploy to Iraq did not fully understand a document he signed admitted to elements of the charges, the judge ruled. Watada was charged with conduct unbecoming and missing movement for staying behind when his brigade shipped out last June, as covered here. (I think war resisters deserve broad coverage, as I have explained.) Watada asserted that, because the war was illegal, his responsibility as an Army officer was to disobey his deployment order. Does any reader know if, under military law, he can face a second court-martial after the mistrial?

Law Would Ban IPods When Crossing Street

“Walk, jog or bicycle across a New York street with an iPod plugged in your ears and you could get slapped with a $100 ticket under a new law proposed by a legislator from Brooklyn. State Sen. Carl Kruger’s bill would also outlaw the use of cell phones, Blackberries, video games or other electronic devices when crossing the street.” (Washington Post)

Should cut down on the incidence of brain tumors in New York as well as pedestrian-vehicle accidents [grin]…

Why Are So Many Choppers Crashing?

“It’s a sad fact of military aviation that helicopters flying in combat are accidents waiting to happen.” They are slow, they fly low, and they have lots of external vulnerable targets. They can be brought down by small-arms fire. Most of the downings that the Pentagon is quick to assert did not result from hostile fire actually turn out indeed to have been shot down. The role of copters in the upcoming ‘surge’ remains to be seen… (Time)

Also: 

Copter Crashes Suggest Shift in Iraqi Tactics: “American officials say the streak strongly suggests that insurgents have adapted their tactics and are now putting more effort into shooting down the aircraft….Some aspects of the recent crashes indicate that insurgents have become smarter about anticipating American flight patterns and finding ways to use old weapons to down helicopters, according to military and witness reports. The aircraft, many of which are equipped with sophisticated antimissile technology, still can be vulnerable to more conventional weapons fired from the ground.” (New York Times )

Excessive Drinking, Not Alcoholism, May Lead To Most Alcohol-related Problems

“Most people realize that too much alcohol can lead to multiple health problems, injuries and violence. Numerous statistics support the accuracy of this perception. Many people also assume that a substantial proportion of people who drink to excess are probably alcoholics. This may not be accurate. A recent study of the general population in New Mexico reveals that, in fact, most alcohol-related problems may be due to excessive drinking — especially binge drinking — among persons who are not alcoholics.” (Science Daily)

I am puzzled by what I think is a specious distinction here. There are many ways to be a problem drinker. Alcoholism is an imprecise term that has little utility and serves to make people either defensive or self-satisfied. It is a common occurrence for people entering treatment for alcohol-related problems to bolster their denial with the assertion that, after all, they are “not alcoholic”. It is true, not all problem drinkers are alcohol-dependent, by which we mean physiologically addicted, needing to drink daily, going into withdrawal if deprived of access to alcohol, and requiring a medical detox to become sober. DSM-IV, the ‘bible’ of official psychiatric diagnoses, makes a distinction between alcohol dependence and alcohol abuse, but IMHO both qualify as “alcoholism”. Just my .02.

Girl fed fatal overdoses, court told

Four-year old Rebecca Riley was found dead on the floor of the family home in Hull on December 13. Prosecutors are charging her parents with first-degree murder for allegedly “regularly giving her drug overdoses, ostensibly to keep her calm and help her sleep”. (Boston Globe)

Rebecca had been diagnosed at age 2 1/2 [sic] with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder and bipolar disorder and was being medicated by a Tufts-New England Medical Center psychiatrist who was also prescribing nearly identical drug regimens for her older brother and sister. The medical center rushed to stand behind their clinician, stating

“Rebecca Riley’s death is a terrible tragedy. The care we provided was appropriate and within responsible professional standards. The appropriate care of our patients is our greatest duty. Dr. Kifuji has outstanding credentials and is respected within her field.”

With the caveat that of course I don’t know the clinical details of Rebecca Riley’s case, I would have to say that there is at least one psychiatric colleague here in Massachusetts who questions the appropriateness of the care little Rebecca received. I find it difficult to imagine how any 2 1/2-year old could possibly be diagnosed with these disorders in the first place. As readers of FmH know, I think the field suffers from rampant overmedicalization of variant behaviors. In particular, I have vented my spleen about the irresponsible epidemic of diagnosing ADHD — there is not an epidemic of ADHD; there is one of diagnosing it! (Perhaps we ought to have a psychopharmacological treatment for disordered diagnostic practices among caregivers…) And childhood bipolar disorder, a controversial diagnosis which seems defined, Alice-in-Wonderland fashion, by little more than the fact that it does not present anything like the adult bipolar disorder with which we are familiar, is the newest abused diagnosis in child psychiatry. Then consider for a moment, even granting the validity of the diagnoses, whether one should ever medicate small children so heavily, or medicate them at all. The only possible consolation from this horrendous travesty of medical care will be if Rebecca’s death becomes a cause celebre that leads to earnest reform. Whatever aspersions one might cast on the parents’ role in their daughter’s death, this entire family should be considered poster children for the affront to human dignity that mental health diagnosis and treatment have become.

“Prescription drugs and behavioral issues were a part of life in the Riley household, the affidavit indicates. Carolyn Riley told investigators she was taking Paxil to deal with depression and anxiety, and Michael Riley admitted he often became verbally abusive with his children and once, a number of years ago, struck his wife. He blamed his temper on bipolar disorder and “intermittent rage disorder,” conditions for which he said he took no medication…”

Your thoughts?

Happy Birthday, Cognitive Dissonance

“Until Leon Festinger published his 1957 book, A Theory of Cognitive Dissonance, the word “dissonance” was pretty much confined to music. Now it’s a standard part of the lexicon for everyone from psychobabblers to political analysts (well, maybe that’s not such a wide range).” (New York Times )

Hmm, sounds like it should be right up my alley, and in fact I find cognitive dissonance a psychological concept of crucial importance. We change our beliefs to avoid the distress of conflicting thoughts. Is it to salve our egos or to avoid agonizing over past mistakes, as the New York Times birthday appreciation poses the question? I actually think there is not much of a distinction. A sense of certainty allows us to have confidence in our minds, our ability to decipher the world and to act decisively. It is one of the foundations of effective functioning. As a mental health clinician, I see every day how devastating it is to lose confidence in the reliability of one’s own thought processes and the lengths to which people will go to avoid doing so.

Colorblind

“Barack Obama would be the great black hope in the next presidential race — if he were actually black.” (Salon)

Debra J. Dickerson, author of The End of Blackness and An American Story, argues that Obama is “black” rather than black, as he cannot claim ancestry from African slaves.

“Lumping us all together.. erases the significance of slavery and continuing racism while giving the appearance of progress. Though actually, it is a kind of progress. And that’s why I break my silence: Obama, with his non-black ass, is doing us all a favor. Since he had no part in our racial history, he is free of it. And once he’s opened the door to even an awkward embrace of candidates of color for the highest offices, the door will stay open. A side door, but an open door.”

I Won’t Be Happy Until I Lose My Legs

I have written before, here (“A New Way to be Mad”; scroll down or use your browser’s search function to find ‘apotemnophilia’) (2000) and here (“Costing an Arm and a Leg”; ditto) (2003), about apotemnophilia. It is back in the news because of this Guardian article, but it seems it has a less tongue-tying name now — BIID or body identity integrity disorder. Here are a spate of recent references (Google) under the new name. [“Squick!” — acm]

Trouble sleeping?

“Insomniacs can take heart from a new drug that makes the brain enter a state similar to narcolepsy.” In narcolepsy, people suddenly fall asleep, probably because neurons that normally release orexins, proteins that promote the waking state, are defective. Swiss researchers have developed an orexin-receptor blocking drug which, in preliminary tests, promotes sleepiness in laboratory animals and human subjects. As opposed to current sedative-hypnotic drugs, this sleep would be more physiological, i.e. natural: “Unlike other sleeping pills, the drug also increases the time spent in REM sleep, when the brain is thought to organise memories, so it may not cause the forgetfulness and memory disruption linked to regular sleeping pill use.” (New Scientist)

Mysterious Wis. Wonder Spot soon to go

Date with a bulldozer: “In a wooded ravine tucked away from the water parks, restaurants and mega-resorts that dominate this tourist town, a piece of history is quietly dying. After more than half a century of wowing tourists (and causing probably more than a few cases of nausea), the Wonder Spot, a mysterious cabin where people can’t stand up straight, water runs uphill and chairs balance on two legs, is no more.

Owner Bill Carney has sold the iconic attraction to the village of Lake Delton for $300,000. The village wants to build a road through the crevice where the Wonder Spot has stood since the 1950s.

Now, the Wonder Spot, one of more than a dozen sites around the nation dubbed ‘gravity vortexes’ and a throwback to postwar, family-oriented tourist attractions, has a date with a bulldozer.” (Yahoo! News)

My family and I never tire of these, having visited a number of such sites (Roadside America ) in the US (as well as abroad). I always detour if one is within reach of our road trip route. (By the way, I subscribe to the theory that these are not-very-mysterious optical illusions.)

U.S. Set to Begin a Vast Expansion of DNA Sampling

“The goal, justice officials said, is to make the practice of DNA sampling as routine as fingerprinting for anyone detained by federal agents, including illegal immigrants. Until now, federal authorities have taken DNA samples only from convicted felons.

…Peter Neufeld, a lawyer who is a co-director of the Innocence Project, which has exonerated dozens of prison inmates using DNA evidence, said the government was overreaching by seeking to apply DNA sampling as universally as fingerprinting.

“Whereas fingerprints merely identify the person who left them,” Mr. Neufeld said, “DNA profiles have the potential to reveal our physical diseases and mental disorders. It becomes intrusive when the government begins to mine our most intimate matters.”

…Immigration lawyers noted that most immigration violations, including those committed when people enter the country illegally, are civil, not criminal, offenses. They warned that the new law would make it difficult for immigrants to remove their DNA profiles from the federal database, even if they were never found to have committed any serious violation or crime. (New York Times )

Scientists offered cash to dispute climate study

“Scientists and economists have been offered $10,000 each by a lobby group funded by one of the world’s largest oil companies to undermine a major climate change report due to be published today.

Letters sent by the American Enterprise Institute (AEI), an ExxonMobil-funded thinktank with close links to the Bush administration, offered the payments for articles that emphasise the shortcomings of a report from the UN’s Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC).” (Guardian.UK)

Furious Seasons: Caveat Emptor

A weblog about mental healthcare from an investigative journalist who has been a mental health consumer.

“…there isn’t much of a free market of ideas in the mental health world–it’s pretty much the mental health establishment versus the anti-psychiatry movement. Let me stress that I am not a member of the latter movement.

What I am is a long-time psych patient who has become quite skeptical about where we are with mental health in this country…. [and] an actual journalist, for what that might be worth in the blogosphere. I am also mentally-ill, having been diagnosed with bipolar disorder (more commonly called manic-depression back then) in 1989. I have been an attentive eyewitness to the psychopharmacological revolution that has swept this nation since about 1990. I have seen and experienced the good. I have seen and experienced the bad. I have lived the in-between.”

Scientists offered cash to dispute climate study

“Scientists and economists have been offered $10,000 each by a lobby group funded by one of the world’s largest oil companies to undermine a major climate change report due to be published today.

Letters sent by the American Enterprise Institute (AEI), an ExxonMobil-funded thinktank with close links to the Bush administration, offered the payments for articles that emphasise the shortcomings of a report from the UN’s Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC).” (Guardian.UK)

Maternal Blood Test Diagnoses Down’s Syndrome

“A blood test for pregnant women may be able to diagnose trisomy 21, which leads to Down’s syndrome, and other chromosomal abnormalities in the fetus, according to a preliminary study.

The new test yielded a false positive rate under 2% for trisomy 21 with a detection rate of 66%, said Ravinder Dhallan, M.D., of Ravgen Inc., here, and colleagues. Their company-sponsored, preliminary study of 60 pregnant women was published online in the Feb. 3 issue of The Lancet.” (MedPage Today)

The test is not yet commercially available, and take note that the detection rate is only around 2/3 although there is a negligible false positive rate. But it is far safer than amniocentesis as a first screen.

Stroke of Insight

“Jill Bolte Taylor, Phd, a neuroanatomist at Indiana University, Bloomington, had a major stroke and discusses it in her fascinating book, My Stroke of Insight: A Brain Scientist’s Personal Journey.

As a brain expert, Dr. Bolte Taylor was able to analyze the physical and mental effects of her stroke — as it occurred, and as she recovered from the life-changing event.”

And:

Injured Brains of Medical Minds: Views from Within Edited by Narinder Kapur: “This book provides a unique perspective on what it is like to be brain-damaged, seen through the eyes of doctors or neurosurgeons who have themselves suffered a brain injury or brain illness. Each of the personal accounts, written over the past 120 years, is accompanied by a commentary written by the author which critically examines the experiences of the sufferer, relating them to current issues in clinical neurology and cognitive neuroscience.”

Through a Glass, Darkly

Jeff Sharlet on How the Christian Right is reimagining U.S. history: “Is “fundamentalism” too limited a word for a belief system of such scope and intimacy? Lately, some scholars prefer “maximalism,” a term meant to convey the movement’s ambition to conform every aspect of society to God. In contemporary America—from the Cold War to the Iraq War, the period of the current incarnation’s ascendancy—that means a culture born again in the image of a Jesus strong but tender, a warrior who hates the carnage he must cause, a man-god ordinary men will follow. These are days of the sword, literally; affluent members of the movement gift one another with real blades crafted to medieval standards, a fad inspired by a bestselling book called Wild at Heart. As jargon, then, “maximalism” isn’t bad, an unintended tribute to Maximus, the fighting hero of Gladiator, which is a film celebrated in Christian manhood guides as almost supplemental scripture. But I think “fundamentalism”—coined in 1920 as self-designation by those ready to do “battle royal for the fundamentals,” hushed up now as too crude for today’s chevaliers—still strikes closest to the movement’s desire for a story that never changes, a story to redeem all that seems random, a rock upon which history can rise.

If the term “fundamentalism” endures, the classic means of explaining it away—class envy, sexual anxiety—do not. We cannot, like H. L. Mencken, writing from the Scopes “monkey” trial of 1925, dismiss the Christian right as a carnival of backward buffoons jealous of modernity’s privileges. We cannot, like the Washington Post, in 1993, explain away the movement as “largely poor, uneducated and easy to command.” We cannot, like the writer Theodor Adorno, a refugee from Nazi Germany who sat squinting in the white light of L.A., unhappily scribbling notes about angry radio preachers, attribute radical religion—nascent fascism?—to Freudian yearning for a father figure.

The old theories have failed. The new Christ, fifty years ago no more than a corollary to American power, twenty-five years ago at its vanguard, is now at the very center. His followers are not anxiously awaiting his return at the Rapture; he’s here right now. They’re not envious of the middle class; they are the middle class. They’re not looking for a hero to lead them; they’re building biblical households, every man endowed with “headship” over his own family. They don’t silence sex; they promise sacred sex to those who couple properly—orgasms more intense for young Christians who wait than those experienced by secular lovers.” (Harper’s)

How many legislators does it take to change a lightbulb?

California may ban conventional lightbulbs by 2012: “A California lawmaker wants to make his state the first to ban incandescent lightbulbs as part of California’s groundbreaking initiatives to reduce energy use and greenhouse gases blamed for global warming…

‘Incandescent lightbulbs were first developed almost 125 years ago, and since that time they have undergone no major modifications,’ California Assemblyman Lloyd Levine said on Tuesday.

‘Meanwhile, they remain incredibly inefficient, converting only about 5 percent of the energy they receive into light.’

Levine is expected to introduce the legislation this week, his office said.

If passed, it would be another pioneering environmental effort in California, the most populous U.S. state. It became the first state to mandate cuts in greenhouse gas emissions, targeting a 25 percent reduction in emissions by 2020.

Compact fluorescent lightbulbs (CFLs) use about 25 percent of the energy of conventional lightbulbs.” (Yahoo! News)

//www.servicelighting.com/catpics/tcp/28955.jpg' cannot be displayed]